Poor road infrastructure and inadequate public transport system remain the key issues in Indian metropolitan areas. Discuss with suitable examples.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Indian metropolitan areas have grown faster than their road networks and public transport: narrow and poorly maintained roads, missing links, waterlogging and encroachments combine with too few buses, slow metro coverage and poor last-mile connectivity, pushing people to private vehicles and producing congestion, accidents and pollution; the remedy lies in public transport-led planning rather than only more roads.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks to discuss the two named issues in metros, their causes and effects, with specific city examples, and to indicate solutions. Balance requires noting recent improvements (metro expansion, e-buses, expressways) as well as persisting gaps.
Answer outline
Introduction
Metropolitan cities such as Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru, Kolkata, Chennai and Hyderabad concentrate population and economic activity, but road space is a small share of land area in older cores and bus fleets have not kept pace with growth.
Road infrastructure problems
- Low road density and narrow roads in old cores; incomplete ring roads and missing links.
- Poor maintenance: potholes, flooding and waterlogging every monsoon, poor drainage on roads.
- Encroachment by parking and hawkers; poor footpaths and pedestrian crossings.
Public transport gaps
- Shortage of buses relative to population in most cities; ageing fleets and unreliable schedules.
- Bus rapid transit setbacks: Delhi's BRT corridor (opened 2008) stopped operating in January 2016 and was dismantled after traffic problems and accidents, while Ahmedabad's Janmarg (2009) shows success is possible.
Consequences
- Rapid growth in private cars and two-wheelers; long commutes and lost productivity; air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.
- Unequal access for poor and women commuters; informal paratransit fills gaps.
Causes
- Fragmented governance across municipal bodies, development authorities, transport departments and police; few functional Unified Metropolitan Transport Authorities.
- Land use and transport not integrated; urban sprawl to the periphery.
- Financial weakness of city bus undertakings and road-centric investment.
Responses
- National Urban Transport Policy (2006).
- PM e-Bus Sewa for city electric buses; Mumbai Trans Harbour Link (Atal Setu, January 2024); Delhi to Meerut Regional Rapid Transit (Namo Bharat, first section October 2023).
- Need: unified authorities, bus priority lanes, parking pricing, walking and cycling infrastructure, and integrated ticketing (National Common Mobility Card).
Conclusion
Metro cities need to plan for moving people, not vehicles; reliable buses, integrated metros and safe streets matter more than road widening alone.
Examples and data to cite
- Atal Setu (Mumbai Trans Harbour Link, 21.8 km including land viaducts) opened on 12 January 2024.
- Delhi to Meerut RRTS (Namo Bharat) first section, Sahibabad to Duhai Depot (17 km), opened on 20 October 2023.
- Ahmedabad Janmarg BRTS began public operations on 14 October 2009.
Facts to remember
- The National Common Mobility Card, first conceived under the National Urban Transport Policy of 2006, was launched on 4 March 2019.