Discuss the most accepted hypothesis regarding the origin of the earth. Add a note on the interior of the earth with sketch.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The most widely accepted explanation is the nebular hypothesis in its modern form: a fragment of a molecular cloud collapsed into the Sun and a flattened protoplanetary disc in which dust grains coagulated into kilometre-sized planetesimals, then planetary embryos that merged into the Earth; the oldest solar system solids date to about 4.567 billion years and the Earth to 4.54 ± 0.05 billion years; its layered interior of crust, mantle, liquid outer core and solid inner core is recognised from seismic discontinuities.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The first part asks for the modern nebular theory with its stages and supporting evidence, contrasted briefly with older hypotheses; the second asks for a labelled sketch and description of the earth's internal layers and discontinuities, based on seismology.
Answer outline
Introduction
Hypotheses on the origin of the earth fall into two groups: monistic (Sun and planets from one nebula: Kant, 1755; modified by Laplace, 1796) and dualistic (involving another star: Chamberlin and Moulton's planetesimal hypothesis, 1901; Jeans' tidal hypothesis, 1917). The modern nebular model is the most widely accepted model of the origin of the solar system.
Solar nebular hypothesis: stages
- Fragments of gravitationally unstable giant molecular clouds collapse to form stars.
- Conservation of angular momentum makes the infalling envelope spin faster, so gas settles near the equatorial plane into a disc around the proto-Sun.
- Condensation: inside the frost line water ice cannot condense, so rocky planets form there; giant planets form beyond it from mostly icy material.
- Accretion: dust grains coagulate into kilometre-sized planetesimals, then planetary embryos; the merger stage that builds terrestrial planets lasts 10 to 100 million years.
- The Earth became layered into crust, mantle and core.
- A collision of the proto-Earth with a Mars-sized protoplanet (sometimes called Theia) is the favoured hypothesis for the formation of the Moon.
Evidence
- Planets have nearly circular, coplanar orbits and move in the same direction as the Sun's rotation.
- Protoplanetary discs have been observed around a very high fraction of stars in young star clusters.
- Calcium-aluminium-rich inclusions in meteorites, the oldest known solar system solids, are 4.5673 ± 0.00016 billion years old; the age of the Earth is 4.54 ± 0.05 billion years.
- Rocky inner planets and icy or gaseous outer planets match the frost line.
Interior of the earth (sketch: concentric layers with depths)
- Crust: oceanic 5 to 10 km thick; continental crust is thicker, with the Moho on average about 35 km (20 to 90 km) below typical continents; the Mohorovičić discontinuity (identified in 1909) is a distinct change in seismic wave velocity.
- Mantle: down to about 2,890 km, with velocities like those through peridotite or dunite below the Moho; the asthenosphere is a ductile, semi-fluid layer, chiefly of the upper mantle, on which the rigid lithosphere moves; a transition zone separates upper and lower mantle.
- Outer core: liquid, from about 2,890 to 5,150 km; convection in it generates the geomagnetic field (dynamo theory).
- Inner core: solid, radius about 1,220 km, below about 5,150 km to the centre at 6,371 km; discovered by Inge Lehmann in 1936.
- Seismic evidence: S waves cannot pass through the liquid outer core and are not detected beyond about 104 degrees from the epicentre; P waves are refracted by the outer core and are not detected between about 104 and 140 degrees.
Conclusion
The nebular model explains the age of the Earth and the arrangement of rocky inner and giant outer planets, while seismic waves reveal the layered interior of crust, mantle, liquid outer core and solid inner core.
Examples and data to cite
- Jack Hills zircons, Western Australia: at least 4.404 billion years, the oldest dated minerals.
- Acasta Gneiss, Canada: zircon ages as old as about 4.03 billion years, the oldest known felsic crustal rocks.
- Inge Lehmann discovered the inner core in 1936.
- Andrija Mohorovičić identified the crust-mantle boundary in 1909.
Facts to remember
- Mean radius of the Earth is about 6,371 km.
- Core-mantle boundary at about 2,890 km depth; inner core boundary at about 5,150 km.
- Lithosphere = crust plus lithospheric mantle; continental lithosphere is about 40 to perhaps 280 km thick, and the oldest oceanic lithosphere about 140 km.
- Earth's average density is 5.515 g/cm³.