Answer the following questions in about 150 words each.
What is granitization ? Explain with reference to the rock forming process.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Granitization is the old hypothesis that granite is formed in place through extreme metasomatism of a pre-existing (commonly metamorphic) rock, fluids moving across a migrating front bringing in elements such as potassium and removing others such as calcium; it was central to the granite controversy, but experimental work had established by the 1960s that granites are of igneous origin, so it is now largely discounted in favour of partial melting of the crust.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define granitization, explain the metasomatic mechanism proposed for it and its link with migmatites, place it in the debate on the origin of granite, and give the present view that granites crystallise from melts produced by partial melting of crustal rocks.
Answer outline
Introduction
Granite can form by crystallisation of a melt or, according to the granitization hypothesis, by in-place chemical conversion of older rocks; the contest between these views was a long running debate in petrology.
Concept and mechanism
- Granitization: granite formed in place through extreme metasomatism, that is by chemical change of an existing solid rock brought about by fluids.
- Fluids were supposed to bring in elements such as potassium and remove others such as calcium, transforming a metamorphic rock into granite.
- The change was supposed to advance across a migrating front; H. H. Read regarded regionally metamorphosed rocks as the result of waves or fronts of metasomatising solutions moving out from a central granitization core.
Migmatites and the debate
- Migmatite (Greek migma, mixture) was first used by J. J. Sederholm in 1907 for rocks of southern Finland; it consists of a light leucosome, a dark melanosome and, when present, an intermediate mesosome, while the paleosome is the remnant of the original rock.
- Holmquist argued that replacive migmatites formed at lower metamorphic grades, with the granitic material derived from the adjacent country rock; Sederholm attributed the granitic partings to melt or fluid (ichor) derived from nearby granites.
- Read's book The Granite Controversy (1957) belongs to this debate.
Why the hypothesis lost ground
- Experimental work had established by the 1960s that granites are of igneous origin: their mineralogical and chemical features can be explained only by crystal-liquid phase relations, showing at least enough melting to mobilise the magma.
- At deep crustal levels the distinction between metamorphism and crustal melting becomes vague: granitic melts can form in place by partial melting of metamorphic rocks, which may be the origin of migmatites, the leucosome being partial melt that has begun to separate from the solid residue.
- If enough partial melt forms it separates and becomes the magmatic parent of granitic rock, and the residue of the source becomes a granulite.
Modern view
- In the Chappell and White classification both I-type and S-type granites are produced by partial melting of crustal rocks, metaigneous and metasedimentary respectively; I-type granites have an initial 87Sr/86Sr below 0.708 and S-type granites typically above 0.708.
- The modern view of migmatites is far from the metasomatic and subsolidus processes proposed during the granitization debate.
Conclusion
Granitization therefore names a proposed rock-forming process of large-scale metasomatic replacement; it is historically important, but granite is now explained by partial melting of the crust, separation of the melt and its crystallisation.
Examples and data to cite
- Migmatites of southern Finland on the Scandinavian craton, for which Sederholm introduced the term in 1907.
- Granulite as the residue left when granitic partial melt separates from its metamorphic source rock.
Facts to remember
- Granitization: an old and largely discounted hypothesis that granite forms in place through extreme metasomatism.
- Migmatite = leucosome (light) + melanosome (dark) ± mesosome; paleosome = remnant of the original rock.
- Experimental work had established by the 1960s that granites are of igneous origin.
- I-type granites: 87Sr/86Sr below 0.708; S-type: typically above 0.708.