What is twinning ? Discuss the different types of twinning found in the feldspar group of minerals.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Twinning is the symmetrical intergrowth of two or more crystals of the same mineral related by a symmetry operation (reflection across a twin plane or rotation about a twin axis) that is not a symmetry element of the single crystal; feldspars show Carlsbad, Baveno and Manebach twins (described from orthoclase, also seen in plagioclase), polysynthetic albite and pericline twins (in plagioclase and microcline) and the combined cross-hatched twinning of microcline.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define twinning with its elements (twin law, twin plane, twin axis, composition plane), classify twins by form (contact, penetration, polysynthetic, cyclic) and origin (growth, transformation, deformation), and then describe each feldspar twin law with its plane or axis, the feldspars in which it occurs and its diagnostic value. Sketches of Carlsbad, Baveno and albite twins earn marks.
Answer outline
Introduction
A twinned crystal is not a random aggregate: adjacent crystals of the same mineral are oriented according to a definite twin law, a symmetry operation relating the segments.
Elements and types of twins
- Twin law: the symmetry operation relating the individuals; twin plane (reflection) written {hkl}; twin axis (rotation) written [uvw]; composition surface: the boundary between the segments, called a composition plane when planar.
- Contact twins share a single composition plane; penetration twins appear to grow through each other; polysynthetic (multiple, lamellar) twins repeat the same law many times on parallel planes, giving striations; cyclic twins repeat around an axis.
- Origin: growth (primary) twins form during crystallisation; transformation (annealing) twins result from a change in crystal system during cooling; deformation (glide) twins form under shear stress after growth.
Simple twins of K-feldspar (orthoclase, sanidine)
- Carlsbad law: twin axis [001] (c axis); a simple twin of monoclinic feldspar such as orthoclase, also found in plagioclase.
- Baveno law: twin plane {021}, in orthoclase.
- Manebach law: twin plane {001}, in monoclinic feldspar such as orthoclase (also known in gypsum).
Polysynthetic twins of triclinic feldspars
- Albite law: twin plane {010}, a law of the triclinic feldspars; plagioclase almost universally shows this polysynthetic twinning, whose striations, seen in hand specimen and as banding under crossed polars, distinguish it from alkali feldspar.
- Pericline law: twin axis [010] (b axis), also a law of the triclinic feldspars plagioclase and microcline.
- The Carlsbad-albite method uses extinction angles measured under the polarising microscope to determine plagioclase composition.
Microcline twinning
- Cross-hatched (gridiron) twinning combines albite and pericline twinning; it results from the transformation of monoclinic orthoclase into triclinic microcline during slow cooling, and it identifies microcline under the microscope.
Diagnostic and petrological value
- Distinguishes orthoclase (simple Carlsbad twins) from plagioclase (polysynthetic albite twins) and microcline (cross-hatched twins).
- In thin section plagioclase composition can be found by the Michel Lévy or Carlsbad-albite methods, the extinction angle varying with the albite fraction.
- Deformation (gliding) twins record stress applied after the crystal formed.
Conclusion
Twinning is a structural phenomenon controlled by crystal symmetry; in feldspars it is so characteristic that the type of twin is often the fastest way to tell orthoclase, microcline and plagioclase apart.
Examples and data to cite
- Labradorite, the characteristic feldspar of gabbro and basalt, showing polysynthetic albite twinning.
- Microcline with gridiron twinning, common in granite and pegmatites.
Facts to remember
- Albite law: twin plane {010}. Pericline law: twin axis [010]. Carlsbad law: twin axis [001]. Baveno: twin plane {021}. Manebach: twin plane {001}.
- In the triclinic system the most commonly twinned crystals are the feldspars plagioclase and microcline.
- Orthoclase is monoclinic; microcline and plagioclase are triclinic.