Explain how primary sedimentary processes influence the mineralogical composition and porosity of the resultant rocks.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Weathering, transport, sorting and deposition progressively remove unstable minerals and keep stable ones, so provenance and the intensity of weathering and transport decide whether a sandstone is a quartz arenite, an arkose or a lithic sandstone; the same processes set sorting, rounding and packing, which control primary porosity, later reduced by compaction and cementation or raised by dissolution.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain cause and effect for two outcomes: mineralogy (compositional maturity) and porosity (textural control). Bring in source, climate, transport, sorting, depositional energy, biogenic and chemical deposition, and show how diagenesis overprints the primary result.
Answer outline
Introduction
The composition and pore system of a sedimentary rock are set first by what the source supplies and what survives weathering and transport, and second by how the grains are sorted and packed at deposition.
Control of mineralogy
- Provenance: a QFL-based provenance chart shows the likely tectonic origin of sandstones; for example forearc basins accumulate sand rich in lithic fragments and plagioclase.
- Weathering: feldspar, mica and other less stable minerals are weathered to clay minerals such as kaolinite, illite or smectite; olivine and Ca-plagioclase weather fastest and quartz is the most resistant (Goldich series), so prolonged weathering concentrates quartz.
- Maturity: with increasing maturity grains become more rounded and the matrix contains less clay; quartz arenites (more than 90% siliceous grains) are texturally mature to supermature, while arkoses (more than 25% feldspar) are poorly rounded and less well sorted.
- Lithic arenites contain abundant unstable rock fragments, and greywackes angular quartz, feldspar and lithic grains in a fine clay matrix.
- Chemical and biogenic deposition: carbonates in tropical lagoons and shallow seas, clay, carbonate mud and silica mud on the abyssal plains, and water-soluble evaporite minerals where water evaporates.
Control of porosity
- Definition: porosity is the ratio of pore volume to total volume.
- Sorting: well sorted sediment, with grains of nearly uniform size, is more porous and permeable than poorly sorted sediment, where smaller particles fill the gaps.
- Packing: for ideal equal spheres porosity is 1 − π/6 ≈ 47.6% in cubic packing and 1 − π/(3√2) ≈ 26.0% in the closest (rhombohedral) packing; sandy surface soils have about 36 to 43%.
- Grain size: in theory the between-grain space depends only on packing, not on grain size.
- Matrix: wackes, with more than 15% clay matrix, have much lower porosity than clean arenites with open pore space.
- Diagenetic overprint: compaction and cementation destroy porosity; dissolution of minerals, dolomitization and fracturing create secondary porosity.
Conclusion
Primary sedimentary processes therefore act as a filter and a sorter: they decide which minerals survive and how grains are packed, setting the starting composition and porosity that diagenesis then modifies and that determines reservoir and aquifer quality.
Examples and data to cite
- Quartz arenite (over 90% siliceous grains, texturally mature) versus arkose (over 25% feldspar, poorly rounded, less well sorted).
- Forearc basin sands rich in lithic fragments and plagioclase, compared with clean, well sorted, porous and permeable sands.
Facts to remember
- Porosity = pore volume / total volume.
- Cubic packing porosity 47.6%; rhombohedral 26.0% (equal spheres; computed, consistent with packing factors 0.52 and 0.74).
- Arenite less than 15% matrix; wacke more than 15%.
- Goldich series: olivine and Ca-plagioclase least stable, quartz most stable at the surface.