How does the tenor of an ore influence its economic viability ? What methods are used to determine it ?
15 marks · directive: How
The core of a good answer
The tenor (grade) of an ore, the concentration of the valuable metal or mineral in it, decides how much saleable product each tonne yields, so together with tonnage, price and costs it fixes the cut-off grade and whether material is ore or waste; it is determined by systematic sampling followed by assay and weighted or geostatistical averaging.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has two parts: the economic role of grade and the techniques for measuring it. A good answer explains cut-off grade, grade tonnage relationships and processing implications, then describes sampling, assaying and averaging methods.
Answer outline
Introduction
Tenor is the concentration of the valuable metal in the ore, for example per cent Cu; porphyry copper deposits average about 0.8 per cent copper by weight.
Influence on economic viability
- Revenue per tonne = grade x recovery x price; costs of mining and processing are incurred per tonne of ore, so higher grade lowers the cost per unit of metal.
- Cut-off grade: the minimum grade that must be met for material to be mined or processed economically; material below it is waste. It changes with metal prices and mining costs.
- Grade tonnage relationship: lowering the cut-off brings more material into ore but lowers its average grade; low grade bulk deposits such as porphyry copper, economic from as low as 0.15 per cent Cu, are mined almost entirely from open pits.
- Unwanted material in a block raises processing costs and can decide whether the block is classed as ore or waste.
Methods of determining grade
- Sampling: soil, sediment and rock samples and drill samples; diamond drill core is photographed and split lengthwise, one half going for assay and the other stored for re-assay; reverse circulation drilling gives cuttings, faster and with less water but with less structural information.
- Correct sampling (Pierre Gy's sampling theory): every particle of the lot should have the same probability of being included in the sample.
- Assaying: fire assay is the accepted standard for valuing gold ore; X-ray fluorescence is a fast non-destructive method; ICP OES is used for platinum and titration for silver.
- Quality: laboratories use validation, calibration, quality control and proficiency testing.
- Averaging: weighted average grade = Σ(grade x length or tonnage) / Σ(length or tonnage); block grades by inverse distance weighting or kriging.
Conclusion
Grade is the single most sensitive parameter of a mineral deposit; reliable sampling and assay are therefore the basis of every reserve statement.
Examples and data to cite
- Porphyry copper deposits average about 0.8 per cent Cu and can be economic from as low as 0.15 per cent Cu because of their huge tonnage.
- Gold can be mined at a lower grade than other minerals, so gold mining produces more waste.
Facts to remember
- Grade (tenor) = mass of valuable constituent / mass of ore x 100 (per cent).
- Cut-off grade separates ore from waste; it changes with metal prices and mining costs.
- Weighted average grade = Σ(gᵢ x lᵢ) / Σ lᵢ for samples of unequal length.
- Kriging is based on the work of D. G. Krige; G. Matheron developed its theory in 1960; it gives the best linear unbiased prediction of block grade.