Evaluate the political and socio-cultural changes occurred in North India after the decline of the Mauryan Empire under the Shunga and Kanva Dynasties.
15 marks · directive: Evaluate
The core of a good answer
Under the Shungas and Kanvas North India moved from a centralised empire to a smaller kingdom under pressure from the Indo-Greeks, ended when the Satavahanas overthrew the Kanvas in 28 BCE, while society saw a Brahmanical revival and early Vasudeva devotion alongside continued, even flourishing, Buddhist art at Bharhut and Sanchi.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Evaluate' requires weighing the changes and their significance, not merely listing them. The answer should cover political shrinkage and foreign pressure, the nature of the Brahmanical revival, the debate on persecution of Buddhists, and achievements in art, language and religion.
Answer outline
Introduction
Pushyamitra Shunga, a Brahmin and commander-in-chief of the last Maurya Brihadratha, assassinated his master and founded the Shunga dynasty; the Kanvas replaced the Shungas in 73 BCE.
Political changes
- The Shunga realm essentially covered the central parts of the old Mauryan Empire, with Pataliputra as capital and later rulers holding court at Besnagar (Vidisha).
- Indo-Greek pressure: the Greeks seem to have maintained control of Mathura, and Kalidasa's Malavikagnimitra describes a battle between a squadron of Greek cavalrymen and Vasumitra, grandson of Pushyamitra.
- The Heliodorus pillar at Besnagar (erected around 113 BCE) records an envoy from the court of the Indo-Greek king Antialcidas to king Bhagabhadra, whose identity is contested, showing diplomacy alongside war.
- Devabhuti, the last Shunga, was killed by his minister Vasudeva Kanva (73 BCE); the four Kanva rulers were ended, according to the Puranas, by the Satavahanas in 28 BCE.
Religious and social changes
- Vedic sacrifice regained royal prestige: an inscription at Ayodhya records that Pushyamitra performed two Ashvamedhas.
- Heliodorus called himself a Bhagavata and set up a 'Garuda-standard of Vasudeva'; its inscriptions are considered the first archaeological evidence of Vasudeva-Krishna devotion.
- The Buddhist Ashokavadana says Pushyamitra burned monasteries and destroyed stupas, but some consider these stories probable exaggerations, and some Indian scholars hold that the Shungas were not intolerant towards Buddhism.
- The majority of scholars date the Manusmriti to between 200 BCE and 200 CE, so its codification of varna and family norms belongs to the broad post-Mauryan age.
Cultural achievements
- Patanjali's Mahabhashya on Panini's grammar was composed in this period.
- Bharhut stupa: railings (c. 125 to 100 BCE) and a great gateway (c. 100 to 75 BCE), with Jataka panels labelled in Brahmi; the gateway phrase 'Suganam raje' may mean 'during the rule of the Shungas', but it could also mean 'during the rule of the Sughanas'.
- Sanchi Stupa 1 was expanded with stone slabs to almost twice its original size, its stone casing and railings dated to c. 150 BCE; at Bharhut, 136 inscriptions mention donors, from Vidisha, Pataliputra, Kosambi, Nasik and elsewhere, including lay people, showing broad patronage.
Conclusion
The Shunga and Kanva period was one of political contraction but cultural vitality; it prepared the synthesis of Brahmanical revival, devotional theism and popular Buddhist art that characterised the following centuries.
Examples and data to cite
- Heliodorus pillar, Besnagar (Vidisha), erected around 113 BCE.
- An inscription at Ayodhya records Pushyamitra's two Ashvamedha sacrifices.
- Bharhut stupa railings, c. 125 to 100 BCE; eastern gateway c. 100 to 75 BCE.
- Patanjali's Mahabhashya, composed in the Shunga period.
Facts to remember
- Pushyamitra Shunga ruled for 36 years (187 to 151 BCE) and was succeeded by his son Agnimitra.
- The Shunga dynasty ended with Devabhuti's assassination by Vasudeva Kanva in about 73 BCE.
- The Kanva dynasty had four rulers (Vasudeva, Bhumimitra, Narayana, Susarman) and ruled from 73 to 28 BCE, when, according to the Puranas, the Satavahanas ended it.