Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
“Muhammad-bin-Tughlaq’s token currency scheme was an innovative economic experiment in medieval India, but its failure exposed the limitations of State control over the medieval economy.” Evaluate.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Evaluate
The core of a good answer
Issuing copper and brass coins to pass at the value of silver (c. 1330) was a bold fiduciary experiment inspired by Chinese practice, but coins that could not be told from forgeries, mass counterfeiting and public refusal collapsed it by 1333, revealing how little a medieval state could control money and markets.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Evaluate' asks for a judgement on both halves of the statement: the innovation and the failure. The answer should give the date, reasons, mechanism and precedents, explain why it failed, and conclude on what it shows about state power. About 150 words.
Answer outline
Introduction
Muhammad bin Tughluq (1325 to 1351) introduced token coins around 1330, after the transfer of the capital to Daulatabad (1327), at a time of heavy military and administrative spending.
Why it was innovative
- Coins of brass and copper were declared legal tender at the value of silver tankas, separating face value from metal value: a fiduciary currency.
- Reasons: a treasury exhausted by gifts and rewards of gold, and, according to Barani, the need for funds to pay the army for planned annexations.
- Inspiration: the Chinese practice of using token coins.
Why it failed
- No control over minting: the coins bore Persian and Arabic inscriptions instead of the royal seal, so official coins could not be told from forgeries, and people made counterfeits at home from brass and copper.
- Foreign traders and common people refused to accept the tokens, and their value collapsed.
- Use of the token currency had stopped by 1333.
What it reveals
- A medieval state lacked the technology, banking system and administrative reach to enforce fiat money; public confidence could not be ordered.
- The tokens were withdrawn within about three years of issue (1330 to 1333), soon after the capital had been moved to Daulatabad in 1327.
Conclusion
The statement is valid: the scheme was ahead of its time, and its failure showed that monetary policy needs trust and enforcement capacity that no fourteenth-century state possessed.
Examples and data to cite
- Token currency introduced c. 1330 and out of use by 1333.
- Transfer of capital to Daulatabad ordered in 1327; return to Delhi c. 1335.
- Ibn Battuta, in Delhi from 1334, does not mention the tokens.
- Barani's Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi (1357) is the main narrative source.
Facts to remember
- Fiduciary or token money: face value exceeds intrinsic metal value.
- The token jital and tanka were minted in brass and copper and valued equal to gold and silver coins.
- The tokens were issued in 1330, after the failed expedition to Deogiri.
- Barani wrote that a treasury was needed to pay the army for annexing inhabited areas.