Critically analyze Barani’s Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi and identify the shortcomings in his account.
15 marks · directive: Critically analyze
The core of a good answer
Barani's Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi (1357) is a major narrative source for the Sultanate up to the early years of Firoz Shah, and the main source for Alauddin Khalji's market reforms, but it is a didactic work resting largely on hearsay, memory and the author's court experience, sketchy on military detail, and coloured by social and religious bias.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Critically analyze' asks for both the value and the problems of the text. The answer should introduce the author and the work, assess its strengths, and then list specific shortcomings with examples, ending with how historians should use it.
Answer outline
Introduction
Ziauddin Barani (1285 to 1357), for seventeen years a nadim (companion) of Muhammad bin Tughluq, fell out of favour after that Sultan's death and wrote the Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi and the Fatawa-i-Jahandari.
Scope and nature
- The narrative runs up to the first six years of Firoz Shah Tughluq's reign; the work is dated 1357.
- Barani held a religious philosophy of history: rulers who followed his precepts for a good Islamic ruler prospered, those who deviated failed; the work is didactic, setting out a sultan's duties.
Strengths
- Insider knowledge of court politics from his seventeen years near Muhammad bin Tughluq, whom he says he advised to abdicate.
- The main source for Alauddin Khalji's market reforms: a numbered list of his regulations, price control and grain measures in the Doab.
- He records Muhammad bin Tughluq's reasoning, such as the need for a treasury to pay the army for planned annexations.
- Later historians depended on it for the period it covers.
Shortcomings
- Reliance on memory and hearsay: he reproduced Alauddin's regulations from memory, about half a century later, not in the text of the royal orders.
- Thin on military history: his description of Alauddin's wars is sketchy, as he did not consult contemporary works.
- Social bias: support for birth-based hierarchy, with ashraf upper castes above ajlaf low castes, in the Fatawa-i-Jahandari.
- Religious bias: open hostility to Hindus, including calls to overpower and degrade the 'infidels'.
- Didactic purpose: the work was meant to set out a sultan's duties toward Islam, so its moral and religious aims shape what it reports.
- Narrow vantage point: his main sources were hearsay and his own experience at court in Delhi.
Conclusion
The Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi remains indispensable for the 14th-century Sultanate, but it must be read as an argument about kingship, checked against Amir Khusrau, Isami, Ibn Battuta, inscriptions and coins.
Examples and data to cite
- Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi dated 1357.
- Barani was a nadim of Muhammad bin Tughluq for seventeen years.
- Fatawa-i-Jahandari: Barani's work on government calling religion and temporal government twins.
- Ibn Battuta, in Delhi from 1334, is a contemporary check on Barani.
Facts to remember
- Barani lived 1285 to 1357, born at Baran (Bulandshahr).
- Barani's Fatawa-i-Jahandari judges the Delhi Sultans from Balban (reigned 1266 to 1287) to Firoz Shah Tughluq.
- Barani was close to Amir Khusrau.
- He ranked ashraf upper castes above ajlaf low castes in the Fatawa-i-Jahandari.