From the Portuguese merchant Domingo Paes’ description of Krishnadevaraya’s reign, assess the socio-economic and cultural uniqueness of the Vijayanagara Empire.
15 marks · directive: Assess
The core of a good answer
Paes, who visited around 1520, portrays Vijayanagara under Krishnadevaraya as a city as large as Rome and 'the best provided city in the world', with aqueducts, artificial lakes, a busy market for precious stones and peaceful ties with coastal ports; read with other evidence on irrigation, the horse trade and the Mahanavami festival, it shows an empire of great wealth and royal display, though it is an outsider's, capital-centred view.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Assess' asks for a judgement of what is distinctive, using Paes as the main source and checking him against other evidence. The answer should arrange Paes' observations under economy, society and culture, explain what made them unique, and note the limits of a foreign traveller's account.
Answer outline
Introduction
Domingo Paes travelled from Portuguese Goa with traders around 1520 and wrote the Chronica dos reis de Bisnaga; Robert Sewell's A Forgotten Empire (1900) includes translations of it and of Fernão Nunes' later account (c. 1535). Krishnadevaraya ruled from 1509 to 1529.
Economy
- City size: Paes judged Vijayanagara 'as large as Rome', with aqueducts and artificial lakes.
- High crop yields at reasonable prices and a busy market of precious stones; he called it the best provided city in the world.
- Paes noted advanced irrigation; the state dug canals to guide river water into irrigation tanks, and water structures in the Daroji valley served agriculture.
- Ports such as Bhatkal, Honnavar and Mangalore were, in Paes' words, seaports 'with whom we are at peace'; Persian horses were landed at Cannanore, and Krishnadevaraya obtained guns and Arabian horses from Portuguese merchants.
Society and kingship
- Paes, with Nunes and Barbosa, praised Krishnadevaraya's administration; the king redressed grievances and punished evildoers on his tours. Hereditary families ruled their territories and paid tribute, each feudatory with its own army.
- The palace had many female attendants, and the devadasi system of temple women existed.
- Wealth in gems and gold flowed through a burgeoning market at the capital.
Culture and ritual
- The Mahanavami festival, linked with the great platform known as the Mahanavami Dibba, whose reliefs show musicians and dancers, was one of the principal public ceremonies displaying royal authority; subordinate rulers and nayakas presented gifts and tribute before the king.
- Temple building continued: the Vitthala temple, begun under Devaraya II, was continued under Krishnadevaraya; he himself wrote the Telugu poem Amuktamalyada.
Limits of the source
- Paes came with a group of traders from Portuguese Goa, and his account centres on the capital: its size, markets and water works.
- Comparisons with Rome reflect a European frame of reference.
- Other evidence, such as Nunes' account, inscriptions and the Hampi monuments, is needed to test and fill out his picture.
Conclusion
Read alongside Nunes, inscriptions and the Hampi ruins, Paes confirms the uniqueness of Vijayanagara as a rich, militarised, temple-centred imperial city whose kingship was expressed through spectacle; his account is best used as a vivid but partial witness.
Examples and data to cite
- Paes visited Vijayanagara c. 1520, during Krishnadevaraya's reign.
- Fernão Nunes' account dates from c. 1535.
- Robert Sewell's A Forgotten Empire (1900) translated both accounts.
- Hampi, the site of Vijayanagara, became a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1986.
Facts to remember
- Krishnadevaraya of the Tuluva dynasty ruled 1509 to 1529.
- Amuktamalyada is Krishnadevaraya's Telugu poem; his court had the Ashtadiggajas poets.
- Hereditary feudatories ruled their territories, paid tribute and kept their own armies.
- Krishnadevaraya obtained guns and Arabian horses from Portuguese merchants and established friendly relations with the Portuguese at Goa in 1510.