Analyze the influence of Persian traditions on the development of architecture and painting under the Mughals. To what extent did these art forms reflect a synthesis of Indian and Persian cultural elements? Discuss.
15 marks · directive: Analyze
The core of a good answer
Persian and Timurid traditions supplied the Mughals with the charbagh garden tomb, the double dome, the iwan, symmetrical planning and, in painting, the atelier, the album and the Persian literary repertoire; but Indian materials, motifs, craftsmen and themes, and later European elements, transformed them into a distinct synthesis seen in Humayun's tomb, Fatehpur Sikri, the Taj Mahal and the Akbari and Jahangiri paintings.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks first for analysis of Persian influence in two arts and then a judgement on how far they were a synthesis. Use named buildings and paintings, separate the Persian and Indian components, and close with a reasoned answer on the degree of synthesis, which varied by reign.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Mughals came from a Timurid-Persian cultural world, and Humayun brought the Persian artists Abd al-Samad and Mir Sayyid Ali to his court; under Akbar, Jahangir and Shah Jahan these traditions met Indian craftsmanship.
Persian influence in architecture
- Humayun's tomb at Delhi (built 1565 to 1572), designed by the Persian architect Mirak Mirza Ghiyas, brought from Herat, and finished by his son: a charbagh setting, the first Persian double dome on a high drum in India, an entrance iwan, a ninefold plan of eight chambers around a central domed hall, and symmetry.
- These Timurid elements matured in the Taj Mahal (1632 to 1653) under Ustad Ahmad Lahori: raised plinth, an outer dome over a false inner dome, iwans, minarets, charbagh, calligraphy and pietra dura inlay; Humayun's tomb inspired its charbagh and hasht-behesht plan.
- Humayun's tomb was the first garden-tomb in the subcontinent and set the precedent for later Mughal royal mausolea.
Indian elements in architecture
- Red sandstone with white marble and chhatris (domed kiosks) on Humayun's tomb.
- Fatehpur Sikri (founded 1571): red sandstone buildings modelled on Timurid forms but with Gujarati influence in palace decor; the Diwan-i-Khas has thirty-six serpentine brackets, the Panch Mahal 176 carved columns, and Jodh Bai's palace shows Rajput influence; the Buland Darwaza (c. 1576 to 1577) is a victory gate.
- The Taj's finials combine Persian and Indian design elements, lotus designs crown its domes, and its four smaller domes are chhatris.
Persian influence in painting
- Mir Sayyid Ali and Abd al-Samad led the atelier in its formative stages; Persian decorated borders, albums and a modified elevated viewpoint continued.
- Persian texts illustrated, and the Hamzanama (1562 to 1577) formed the early style.
Indian elements in painting
- Indian painters Daswanth and Basawan; illustrated versions of the epics, the Razmnama and the Ramayana.
- Mansur's naturalistic studies of animals and plants; Jahangir encouraged studies of birds, flowers and animals.
- European single-point perspective, which Jahangir encouraged, and Keshav Das's European rendering of space and volume added a third element.
Conclusion
Mughal art began as an import of Persian forms but became a true synthesis in which Indian craftsmen and themes were equal partners; the degree of synthesis was highest under Akbar, refined under Jahangir and Shah Jahan, and the result was a style that neither Persia nor earlier India had produced.
Examples and data to cite
- Humayun's tomb, architects chosen by Bega Begum, built 1565 to 1572.
- Taj Mahal built 1632 to 1653, chief architect Ustad Ahmad Lahori.
- Hamzanama produced 1562 to 1577.
- Razmnama illustrated at the Mughal court from 1585.
Facts to remember
- Charbagh: four-part Persian garden divided by water channels.
- Double dome: an outer shell raised over a lower inner dome.
- Hasht bihisht: ninefold plan with a central domed chamber and eight surrounding chambers.
- Humayun's tomb and the Taj Mahal are UNESCO World Heritage Sites.