Would you consider eighteenth century in India an era of ‘Dark Age’, or a period of economic growth? Elucidate.
20 marks · directive: Elucidate
The core of a good answer
The 'Dark Age' view, drawn from the decline of Mughal central power, invasions, wars and agrarian distress, holds for Delhi and parts of the north, but the same century saw strong successor states, powerful bankers, a quarter of the world's textile trade in Indian hands and a prosperous Bengal until 1757; it was an age of political decentralisation with regionally uneven economic fortunes, not uniform darkness.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Elucidate' asks for a clear explanation of both positions with evidence, leading to a reasoned view. The answer should present the evidence of decline, the evidence of continued economic activity in the regions, and should recognise that the picture changes after mid-century with Company rule.
Answer outline
Introduction
The 18th century in India runs from the death of Aurangzeb (1707) to the establishment of British paramountcy; historians disagree whether it was a time of anarchy and decline or of regional dynamism.
Arguments for a 'Dark Age'
- Collapse of Mughal central authority and succession wars after 1707, the subject of William Irvine's Later Mughals and Jadunath Sarkar's Fall of the Mughal Empire (four volumes, 1932 to 1938); Nizam-ul-Mulk established Hyderabad as an independent kingdom, and Bengal gained de facto independence.
- Invasions: Nadir Shah defeated the Mughals at Karnal (24 February 1739) and sacked Delhi in March 1739; Ahmad Shah Abdali's campaigns culminated in Panipat in 1761.
- Agrarian crisis view: Irfan Habib (The Agrarian System of Mughal India, 1963) argues that excessive exploitation of the peasantry caused the collapse; revolts of Jats, Satnamis and Sikhs spread disorder; grain wages fell behind in the 18th century.
- Late-century disasters: Plassey (1757) and the diwani (1765) shifted Bengal's revenue to the East India Company, and about 10 million people starved in the Bengal famine of 1770.
Arguments for growth and dynamism
- The historian Markovits argues that the very prosperity of the empire inspired the provinces to seek a high degree of independence, so decentralisation need not mean economic collapse.
- Successor states such as the Marathas, the Nawabs of Awadh and the Nizams of Hyderabad took over Mughal territory; the Marathas collected chauth and sardeshmukhi and ruled from Pune.
- Banking: the Jagat Seths of Bengal acted as bankers to the Nawab and to the European companies alike.
- Trade: India held a 25% share of the global textile trade and Indian textiles 38% of the West African trade in the early 18th century; Bengal, the main cotton centre, was prosperous until 1757 and the foremost muslin exporter in the world.
- Europe's fashion came to depend on Indian textiles; muslin became highly popular in 18th-century France.
Balanced view
- Experiences differed by region and decade: Delhi suffered invasion and sack, while Bengal prospered until 1757.
- After mid-century, Company rule redirected Bengal's revenue, and Indian textile exports later collapsed as Britain industrialised and imposed discriminatory tariffs.
Conclusion
Calling the 18th century a 'Dark Age' generalises from the fall of Delhi; the better description is a period of political transition with continuing and in places expanding economic activity, which the later colonial takeover cut short.
Examples and data to cite
- Nadir Shah sacked Delhi in 1739.
- Third Battle of Panipat, 14 January 1761.
- Battle of Plassey, 1757; Bengal famine, 1770.
- Irfan Habib's The Agrarian System of Mughal India, 1556 to 1707 (1963); Muzaffar Alam's The Crisis of Empire in Mughal North India (1986); C.A. Bayly's Rulers, Townsmen and Bazaars: North Indian Society in the Age of British Expansion, 1770 to 1870 (1983).
Facts to remember
- Aurangzeb died in 1707.
- The governors of Hyderabad, Bengal and Awadh established independent kingdoms after Aurangzeb.
- Jagat Seth: bankers to the Nawab of Bengal and to the European companies.
- India had a 25% share of the global textile trade in the early 18th century.