Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each :
“Permanent settlement policy resulted in an unfair distribution of assessment, particularly when there was no survey.”
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
The Permanent Settlement of 1793 fixed the state's demand for ever at 89 per cent of the rent then collected, without a survey of the land, so the burden fell unevenly from the start: defaulting estates were sold under the 'Sunset Law', many passed to absentee purchasers, and the cultivators' position was left unprotected while the state gave up any share in later growth.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The statement links the inequity of the Permanent Settlement to the absence of a survey. A critical examination should explain how the assessment was made, show the inequities between estates, between state and zamindar, and between zamindar and ryot, and weigh them against the policy's intended benefits.
Answer outline
Introduction
In 1790 the Court of Directors issued a ten-year (decennial) settlement with the zamindars, which was made permanent in 1793 under Lord Cornwallis; it was introduced first in Bengal and Bihar and later in Varanasi and the northern districts of Madras.
Assessment without a survey
- The state demand was fixed at 89 per cent of the rent, with 11 per cent left to the zamindar, and the amount was to remain unchanged for ever.
- If, as the statement says, the demand was fixed without a survey of each estate's true capacity, it could be heavy for some estates and light for others, and that inequality was then frozen permanently.
- John Shore argued that it would take time before the zamindars realised the settlement was genuine, but Cornwallis went ahead.
Consequences
- Under the 'Sunset Law' failure to pay on time led to the sale of the estate to the highest bidder, and many estates changed hands.
- Many new holders were absentee landlords who managed their land through agents, distant from the cultivators.
- Because the demand was fixed for ever, the state could not share in later increases in rent from extension of cultivation.
The other side
- The British expected a regular flow of tax income once the revenue demand was fixed.
- They hoped for 'improving landlords' who would invest in the land, and for a class that would be loyal to the British.
- Land reform after independence was still incomplete everywhere except West Bengal in the 1950s, showing how deeply the system had entrenched itself.
Conclusion
The absence of a survey made the Permanent Settlement unequal from the start and left the cultivator unprotected; the assured revenue it gave the state came at the cost of fairness to ryots and of future public income.
Examples and data to cite
- Decennial settlement of 1790, made permanent in 1793.
- Regulations of 1 May 1793 under which the system spread across northern India.
- The 'Sunset Law': sale of defaulting estates to the highest bidder.
Facts to remember
- The state's share was fixed at 89 per cent of the rent; the zamindar kept 11 per cent.
- The decennial settlement was issued in 1790 and made permanent in 1793.
- The settlement was introduced first in Bengal and Bihar and later in Varanasi and the northern districts of Madras.
- The British expected a regular revenue and a loyal class of improving landlords.