Was the Moplah Rebellion in Malabar an expression of anti-landlord and anti-foreign discontent ? Discuss.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The Mappila (Moplah) rebellion of 1921 was both: it grew out of long agrarian grievances of Mappila tenants against jenmi landlords whose ownership British courts had recognised, and it was ignited by the Khilafat movement against British rule, though it also took a communal turn that alienated Hindus and led the Congress to repudiate it.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Discuss' requires examining the different dimensions of the revolt and reaching a reasoned view. The answer should establish the agrarian (anti-landlord) and anti-colonial (anti-foreign) strands with evidence, then address the communal violence and differing interpretations.
Answer outline
Introduction
The rebellion broke out in August 1921 in the Ernad and Valluvanad taluks of Malabar district (Madras Presidency) after a police action at Tirurangadi; martial law was imposed and the situation was brought under control by the end of 1921.
Anti-landlord roots
- Land in Malabar was held by jenmis, mainly Namboothiri Brahmins and Nair chieftains, and leased through tenures such as kanam; verumpattam holders had only one-year leases.
- British courts recognised the jenmis as owners, and this legal recognition gave them the right to evict tenants.
- Twenty-nine Mappila outbreaks between 1836 and 1919 were suppressed, showing long-standing agrarian tension; William Logan wrote on the hardship of the Mappilas.
Anti-foreign (anti-colonial) roots
- The Khilafat movement was introduced into Malabar on 28 April 1920, at the Manjeri district conference, and spread anti-British feeling among Mappilas.
- The trigger came on 20 August 1921, when police arrested Khilafat volunteers and seized records at the Mambaram mosque in Tirurangadi.
- Variyankunnath Kunjahammad Haji took command on 24 August 1921 and ran a rebel state with its own passport, currency and taxation.
- Repression was severe: martial law, the Wagon tragedy (10 November 1921) in which 64 of 100 prisoners suffocated, and deportations, mainly to the Andaman Islands (unofficial estimates put these at 20,000).
Communal dimension and interpretations
- Hindus were killed and forcibly converted; Arya Samaj claims put the figures at about 600 killed and 2,500 converted, while Roland Miller gives a range of 200 to 2,500 conversions.
- The Indian National Congress repudiated the movement, which remained isolated from the wider nationalist movement.
- In 1971 the Government of Kerala recognised active participants as 'freedom fighters', a decision that remains debated.
Conclusion
The rebellion fused agrarian protest against landlords with anti-British mobilisation under the Khilafat banner, but its communal violence shows the limits of that fusion and weakened Hindu-Muslim unity in Malabar.
Examples and data to cite
- Tirurangadi incident, 20 August 1921, began the main rising.
- Wagon tragedy, 10 November 1921: 64 of 100 Mappila prisoners died in a closed railway wagon on the way from Tirur to the Central Prison, Bellary.
- Official figures: 2,337 rebels killed, 1,652 injured and 45,404 imprisoned.
- Kerala government's recognition of participants as freedom fighters, 1971.
Facts to remember
- Jenmi: hereditary landholder; kanam: a form of tenure; verumpattam: a one-year lease.
- Twenty-nine Mappila outbreaks were suppressed between 1836 and 1919.
- The main centres were Ernad and Valluvanad taluks of Malabar district.
- The Khilafat movement was introduced into Malabar district on 28 April 1920.