“In my belief, congress is to tottering to its fall and one of my great ambitions which in India is to assist it to a peaceful demise.” Comment.
10 marks · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
Lord Curzon's dismissal of the Congress in 1900 as 'tottering to its fall' reflected his belief that it was no longer an effective force; instead his Partition of Bengal (1905) revived and radicalised nationalism through the Swadeshi movement, so the prophecy proved wrong.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for comment on Curzon's statement: identify the speaker and context, explain why he thought the Congress was weak, and assess the outcome of his policies on the national movement.
Answer outline
Introduction
The words are Lord Curzon's (Viceroy from 6 January 1899 to 18 November 1905), who in 1900 dismissed the Congress as 'tottering to its fall', at a time when the Congress was led by Moderates.
Why Curzon thought so
- Curzon believed that the Congress was no longer an effective force.
- The Moderates' petitions and resolutions had produced limited results, and the Congress was confined largely to the educated elite.
- Official goodwill had faded early: Lord Dufferin approved the first session in 1885, but his support was short-lived.
Curzon's measure that backfired
- The Partition of Bengal was announced by Curzon and took effect on 16 October 1905, a day that coincided with Raksha Bandhan.
- Many saw it as a deliberate attempt to divide the Bengal Presidency on religious grounds.
The outcome
- Partition provoked the Swadeshi movement, with the boycott of British goods and of government schools.
- The Extremists, with leaders such as Aurobindo and Tilak, gained ground; the Congress brought Dadabhai Naoroji to preside over its Calcutta session of 1906 to hold the party together.
- At the Surat session of December 1907 the Congress split formally into two factions, Moderates and Extremists.
- The partition was annulled, an annulment announced at the Delhi Durbar on 12 December 1911 under Lord Hardinge; the Congress, far from dying, became the main vehicle of the national movement.
Conclusion
Curzon's wish to give the Congress a 'peaceful demise' produced the opposite: the Partition of Bengal helped transform a cautious elite body into a mass-based national movement.
Examples and data to cite
- Curzon's remark of 1900 that the Congress was 'tottering to its fall'.
- Partition of Bengal, effective 16 October 1905.
- Calcutta session of the Congress, 1906, with Dadabhai Naoroji.
- Surat split, December 1907.
- Annulment of the partition announced at the Delhi Durbar, 12 December 1911.
Facts to remember
- Curzon was Viceroy from 6 January 1899 to 18 November 1905.
- Dadabhai Naoroji was Congress president three times: 1886 to 1887, 1893 to 1894 and 1906 to 1907.
- The Partition of Bengal was annulled in 1911, announced at the Delhi Durbar.
- The Surat split between Moderates and Extremists took place in 1907.