‘Subhas Chandra Bose and the Indian National Army awakened an unprecedented sense of national consciousness among both the Indian armed forces and masses.’ Evaluate.
20 marks · directive: Evaluate
The core of a good answer
Militarily the INA failed, but its example and above all the Red Fort trials of 1945 to 1946 produced an extraordinary wave of nationalist feeling that cut across religion and reached the armed forces, as the Royal Indian Navy mutiny showed; the statement is largely valid, though the INA's impact was felt mostly after its defeat and must be weighed alongside the wider national movement.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Evaluate' requires a judgement on the strength of the claim. The answer should outline Bose and the INA, show the evidence of awakened consciousness among the masses and the armed forces, and weigh military failure and other factors.
Answer outline
Introduction
The first Indian National Army was formed in 1942 under Mohan Singh from Indian prisoners of war in South-East Asia, backed by the Indian Independence League led by Rash Behari Bose; it was revived and reorganised after Subhas Chandra Bose arrived in 1943, and the Azad Hind government was formed in October 1943.
Bose and the INA
- Bose, Congress president in 1938 and 1939, founded the All India Forward Bloc in June 1939, escaped British surveillance in Calcutta in January 1941, and reached Japanese-held Sumatra in May 1943; in July 1943 Rash Behari Bose handed over control to him.
- His call 'Dilli Chalo' (On to Delhi) motivated INA troops; the Rani of Jhansi Regiment, a women's unit, was headed by Capt. Lakshmi Swaminathan (later Lakshmi Sahgal).
- INA forces were in action with the Japanese in the Imphal and Kohima area in early 1944, and the Japanese offensive failed; Bose died on 18 August 1945 after an air crash in Formosa (Taiwan).
Awakening among the masses
- The first Red Fort trial (November to December 1945) of Shah Nawaz Khan, Prem Sahgal and Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon, one Muslim, one Hindu and one Sikh, became a symbol of unity.
- The Congress defence committee included Bhulabhai Desai, Tej Bahadur Sapru and Jawaharlal Nehru; Congress and Muslim League flags were flown together at protests.
- Calcutta saw several upsurges between November 1945 and February 1946.
- Auchinleck, Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Army, was forced to commute the sentences of the three defendants of the first trial, an admission that public opinion could not be ignored.
Awakening in the armed forces
- The Royal Indian Navy revolt began on 18 February 1946 as a strike by ratings at HMIS Talwar in Bombay; its charter of demands included the unconditional release of all INA personnel.
- Royal Indian Air Force units in Bombay also saw unrest, and an army mutiny took place at Jabalpur in the last week of February 1946.
- In British circles confidence in the loyalty and reliability of the Royal Indian Navy was shattered.
Limits
- The INA's military contribution was small and dependent on Japan, whose Imphal and Kohima offensive failed.
- Bose had earlier broken with the Congress leadership: he resigned the presidency in 1939 and was later expelled.
- Mass consciousness had already been built by decades of earlier movements; the INA intensified it at a critical moment rather than creating it.
Conclusion
Bose and the INA did awaken an unprecedented patriotic response, especially through the trials and the impact on the armed forces, and this helped convince Britain that India could not be held; but their effect was one strand of a broader national movement.
Examples and data to cite
- Azad Hind government formed, October 1943, based in Japanese-occupied Singapore.
- First INA trial at the Red Fort, November to December 1945.
- Royal Indian Navy revolt, Bombay, from 18 February 1946.
- Jabalpur army mutiny, last week of February 1946.
Facts to remember
- Mohan Singh led the first INA in 1942, backed by the Indian Independence League under Rash Behari Bose.
- The INA defendants were charged with 'waging war against the King' under Section 121 of the Indian Penal Code.
- Japan gave the Azad Hind government limited jurisdiction over the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, which were renamed Shaheed and Swaraj.
- Claude Auchinleck was Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Army during the trials.