Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each :
“Globalization tends to benefit the privileged sections of society and further marginalized those who are already disadvantaged.”
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
Globalisation has widened income inequality within countries, rewarding capital and skilled workers while weakening the bargaining position of labour, but inequality between countries has fallen as developing economies grew faster, so its distributive outcome depends heavily on state policy rather than being fixed.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The statement is a critique of globalisation's distributive effects. 'Critically examine' requires evidence for the claim, evidence against it, and a reasoned verdict that the outcome is shaped by institutions and policy, all in about 150 words.
Answer outline
Introduction
Globalisation, the growing integration of economies through trade, capital flows, technology and migration, was given an institutional framework by the World Trade Organization, established on 1 January 1995.
Arguments supporting the statement
- Within-country income inequality has increased during the globalisation period, partly because workers with more education and skills can find higher-paying work.
- Labour-intensive production migrates to areas with lower labour costs, and unions are at a disadvantage when employers can relocate or outsource; critics link this 'race to the bottom' to poor working conditions, low wages and job insecurity.
- Foreign firms may gain at the expense of local companies that would otherwise dominate the domestic market, and tax shelters produce a tax incidence that disadvantages the poor.
- Joseph Stiglitz, Globalization and Its Discontents (2002), argued that Third World citizens carried much of the costs and few of the benefits of IMF loans.
Arguments against
- Global inequality between countries has lessened because developing countries have grown much faster; China, India and Bangladesh greatly narrowed inequality through economic expansion.
- Poverty rates fell in China (from 20 to 15 percent) and Bangladesh (from 43 to 36 percent) in the period the source describes, and the poorest fifth in China saw 3.8 percent annual income growth.
- Government funding of education can soften the rise in inequality that comes from the premium on skills.
Historian's view
- The large demonstrations that greeted the WTO's Seattle conference in 1999 reflected a widespread sense that the gains were unevenly shared, not that everyone lost.
Conclusion
The statement holds true where states leave openness unbuffered; with investment in human capability and safety nets, globalisation can be inclusive rather than marginalising.
Examples and data to cite
- WTO established 1 January 1995.
- Seattle WTO conference and demonstrations, 1999.
- Stiglitz, Globalization and Its Discontents (2002).
Facts to remember
- Globalisation involves trade, finance, technology, migration and culture.
- Within-country income inequality has risen during globalisation while inequality between countries has lessened.
- The Kuznets hypothesis (1955) linked growth to rising then falling inequality.
- Stiglitz called the Washington Consensus policy of free markets 'a blend of ideology and bad science'.
- The Washington Consensus (term first used by John Williamson, 1989) promoted trade liberalisation, privatisation and financial liberalisation.