Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each :
‘The July Revolution of 1830 marked a significant turning point in the advancement of liberalism and constitutionalism in France.’ Analyse.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Analyse
The core of a good answer
The July Revolution ended the Bourbon attempt at royal absolutism, made the monarchy rest on a revised Charter accepted by the nation, abolished censorship and gave the chambers legislative initiative, a real gain for liberalism; but the July Monarchy remained an oligarchy of property with about 170,000 voters, so the turning point was partial and led to the revolution of 1848.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks to break down the Revolution's constitutional and liberal consequences and to weigh them. 'Analyse' needs causes, the changes in the Charter of 1830, the wider European effect, and the limits that kept the regime narrow.
Answer outline
Introduction
Charles X (1824 to 1830), with Polignac as chief minister, set out to alter the Charter of 1814 by decree: the July Ordinances, signed on 25 July 1830 and published on 26 July, dissolved the Chamber of Deputies, suspended the liberty of the press and excluded the commercial middle class from future elections.
The revolution
- Paris rose on 27 July 1830 in the 'Trois Glorieuses'; Charles X abdicated on 2 August, and Louis-Philippe of Orléans became 'King of the French', replacing the principle of hereditary right by that of popular sovereignty.
Liberal and constitutional gains
- The Charter was revised on 7 August 1830 and sworn by Louis-Philippe on 9 August; it was seen as imposed on the king by the nation rather than granted by him.
- Catholicism ceased to be the state religion and became the religion professed by the majority of the French; press censorship was abolished; the tricolour was restored.
- Both chambers gained the right to initiate laws; the voting age fell to 25 and the tax qualification to 200 francs, and the electorate roughly doubled to about 170,000.
Limits
- Only about 1 in 170 Frenchmen voted (240,000 by 1846); the regime was dominated by the wealthy bourgeoisie, and Guizot's answer to the disenfranchised was 'enrichissez-vous' (enrich yourselves).
- Workers' risings (the Lyon canut revolts of November 1831 and April 1834) were put down, and the laws of 9 September 1835 restricted freedom of the press.
European impact
- It inspired the Belgian revolution and independence, and failed risings in Poland and Italy.
Conclusion
1830 settled that France would be a constitutional, parliamentary monarchy, a lasting liberal gain; its narrow social base meant that the further advance to universal suffrage came only after the February Revolution of 1848.
Examples and data to cite
- July Ordinances, 25 to 26 July 1830.
- Charter of 1830, 14 August 1830.
- Belgian independence, 1830 to 1831.
- Lyon canut revolts, 1831 and 1834.
- February Revolution, 1848.
Facts to remember
- Louis-Philippe ruled 1830 to 1848 as King of the French.
- Deputies had to be at least 30 and pay 500 francs in tax.
- The double vote of the Restoration was abolished.
- Polignac was Charles X's chief minister in 1830.
- Power shifted from the noble landowners towards the wealthy bourgeoisie and urban merchants.