The Industrial Revolution in England accelerated the decline of traditional Indian handicrafts and cottage Industries. Critically examine the factors responsible for this decline and its impact on the Indian economy and society.
20 marks · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
Machine-made British goods, protected in Britain by prohibitive duties while entering India almost duty free, ruined much of India's textile manufacture once the Company's trade monopoly was ended in 1813; India changed from an exporter of manufactures to an exporter of raw materials, and nationalist economists such as R. C. Dutt described the loss of livelihood of millions of artisans.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for causes and consequences of the decline of Indian crafts linked to Britain's Industrial Revolution. 'Critically examine' requires distinguishing external (industrial competition) from internal and political causes, assessing impacts, and noting the historiographical debate on deindustrialisation.
Answer outline
Introduction
R. C. Dutt held that India in the eighteenth century was a great manufacturing as well as a great agricultural country; British machine production reversed this position within a few decades.
Factors: the Industrial Revolution
- Indian cottons and silks could be sold profitably in Britain at prices 50 to 60 percent below British goods, so British mills, later driven by steam, grew behind protection.
- The Charter Act of 1813 ended the East India Company's trade monopoly with India, opening the market to British manufactures.
- One-way free trade: Indian goods faced duties of 70 or 80 percent of their value, or outright prohibition, in Britain, while British goods were forced on India without paying any duty.
Factors: political and social
- Dutt argued that the Company and the British Parliament discouraged Indian manufactures to favour England's industries.
- Commercial cultivation penetrated village society and made it more vulnerable to market forces; indigo planters gave cash advances to peasants and sometimes coerced them.
Impact on economy
- Deindustrialisation: in Dutt's words, the population of India lost one great source of their wealth, as millions of artisans lost their earnings.
- By the 1820s to 1840s raw materials, chiefly raw cotton, opium and indigo, made up most of India's exports; opium alone was 40 percent by the late 1840s.
- British textile imports into India rose from £5.2 million in 1850 to £18.4 million in 1896.
Impact on society and politics
- Dutt highlighted growing polarisation between town and country and recurrent devastating famines.
- Nationalists made the economic critique central: Dadabhai Naoroji's drain theory and Dutt's two-volume economic history; the Swadeshi movement (from 7 August 1905) sought to reduce reliance on imported goods by building up domestic production.
Critical note
- The deindustrialisation thesis comes largely from the nationalist school (the Metcalfs call Dutt's account a classic nationalist account), and dependence on raw materials was itself unstable: demand for Indian cotton rose during the American Civil War but fell after 1865.
Conclusion
The Industrial Revolution supplied the cheap machine goods, but colonial trade policy turned competition into destruction; the result was a more agrarian Indian economy exporting raw materials.
Examples and data to cite
- British textile imports into India rose from £5.2 million (1850) to £18.4 million (1896).
- Charter Act of 1813.
- First passenger railway, Bombay to Thane, 1853.
- R. C. Dutt, The Economic History of India Under Early British Rule (1902) and in the Victorian Age (1904).
- Dadabhai Naoroji, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901).
Facts to remember
- Naoroji's drain theory argued that British rule drained wealth from India.
- The Swadeshi movement was formally started at the Town Hall, Calcutta, on 7 August 1905, against the partition of Bengal.
- By the late 1840s opium made up 40 percent of India's exports.
- Demand for Indian cotton rose during the American Civil War and fell after the war ended in 1865.