‘The League of Nations failed to achieve its objectives of maintaining international peace and security.’ Analyse the major factors responsible for its failure during the period 1919-1946.
10 marks · directive: Analyse
The core of a good answer
The League failed in its central task of preventing aggression because it lacked the United States and often other great powers, depended on unanimity and voluntary sanctions without armed force, was tied to the resented Versailles settlement, and its leading members put self-interest above collective security in the crises of the 1930s.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Analyse' needs the factors separated (structural, membership, political, economic) and tested against the major crises, with a brief note on the League's successes so that the failure is judged precisely.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Covenant was Part I of the Treaty of Versailles (signed 28 June 1919) and the League came into being on 10 January 1920, with collective security as its core idea.
Structural weaknesses
- Decisions of both the Assembly and the Council required unanimity, with some exceptions such as procedural matters.
- No standing army; sanctions depended on members' willingness.
Membership
- The US Senate rejected the treaty (vote of 19 March 1920), so the US never joined.
- Germany joined only in 1926; Japan and Germany left in 1933, Italy in 1937 and Spain in 1939, and the USSR was expelled in December 1939 for invading Finland.
Failures in crises
- Corfu (1923): the dispute was settled by the Conference of Ambassadors, not the League.
- Manchuria (1931): the Mukden incident was a decisive setback because the League's major members refused to tackle Japanese aggression; the Lytton Report passed 42 to 1 in 1933, and Japan left the League.
- Abyssinia (1935): sanctions did not ban oil or close the Suez Canal, and were lifted on 4 July 1936; the leaked Hoare-Laval plan (1935) showed Britain and France bargaining with the aggressor.
Wider causes
- The League lacked its own armed force and depended on the victorious Allied Powers to enforce its resolutions, so it was only as strong as their will.
Balance
- Successes: the Åland Islands settlement (1921), the Nansen passport for stateless refugees and the International Labour Organization (1919).
Conclusion
The League ceased operations on 18 April 1946, the United Nations having effectively replaced it in 1945; its record shows that collective security needs the commitment of the great powers.
Examples and data to cite
- Åland Islands decision, 1921.
- Mukden incident, 1931, and Lytton Report adopted 1933.
- Italian invasion of Abyssinia, 1935.
- Soviet expulsion after invading Finland, December 1939.
Facts to remember
- The League's seat was Geneva.
- Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points (1918) proposed a general association of nations.
- Germany was admitted on 8 September 1926.
- The USSR was expelled on 14 December 1939.
- The US Senate vote of 19 March 1920 (49 to 35) fell short of the two-thirds majority required.