Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(a) “The ‘Doctrine of Pleasure’ in its absolute unrestricted application does not exist in India.” Elucidate with regard to service jurisprudence.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Elucidate
The core of a good answer
Article 310 adopts the English rule that civil servants hold office during the pleasure of the President or Governor, but the Constitution itself qualifies it: the opening words "except as expressly provided by this Constitution", the procedural shield of Article 311, protected tenure for some constitutional functionaries, and judicial review of the action for mala fides or irrelevant grounds mean the pleasure cannot be exercised arbitrarily.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks you to make the statement clear by showing where the English doctrine came from, how Article 310 adopts it and how the Constitution and the courts have cut it down. A good answer of about 150 words names the textual limits and two or three leading cases.
Answer outline
Introduction
In England a servant of the Crown held office at the Crown's pleasure and could be dismissed at will unless legislation provided otherwise (pleasure doctrine). Article 310(1) of the Constitution of India adopts the rule, but only "except as expressly provided by this Constitution".
Textual limits
- Article 311(1): no member of a civil service may be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to the one that appointed him.
- Article 311(2): no dismissal, removal or reduction in rank except after an inquiry in which the person is told of the charges and given a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
- Second proviso to Article 311(2) allows dispensing with the inquiry only in three cases: (a) conviction on a criminal charge, (b) inquiry not reasonably practicable, for reasons recorded in writing, (c) inquiry not expedient in the interest of the security of the State.
- Article 310(2): a person appointed under a special contract may get compensation if, before the agreed period ends, the post is abolished or he is required to vacate it for reasons not connected with misconduct.
- Some constitutional functionaries are outside the ordinary pleasure: the Comptroller and Auditor General (Article 148(1)) and the Chief Election Commissioner (proviso to Article 324(5)) can be removed only in like manner and on like grounds as a Judge of the Supreme Court.
Judicial gloss
- Parshotam Lal Dhingra v. Union of India ([1958] SCR 828): Article 311 is attracted where termination is by way of punishment, tested by whether the servant had a right to the post or is visited with evil consequences.
- Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel (1985): the pleasure doctrine rests on public policy and the public interest; the second proviso excludes the inquiry and hearing in its three cases, but the action remains open to judicial review on grounds such as mala fides or irrelevant considerations.
- B.P. Singhal v. Union of India ((2010) 6 SCC 331) examined the doctrine of pleasure in the context of the removal of Governors.
Conclusion
Pleasure in India is therefore a power held in trust and hedged by the Constitution, not the unfettered will of the Crown.
Examples and data to cite
- Shamsher Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1974): where the Constitution speaks of the satisfaction of the President or Governor, it is not his personal satisfaction but the satisfaction of his Council of Ministers.
- Union of India v. Mohd. Ramzan Khan ((1991) 1 SCC 588): the inquiry report must be supplied to the charged employee; Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar (1993) required a copy of the Inquiry Officer's report to be furnished before the penalty.
Facts to remember
- Article 309: subject to the Constitution, Acts of the appropriate Legislature may regulate recruitment and conditions of service, and until then the President or Governor may make rules.
- The 42nd Amendment (1976) removed the requirement to give the employee an opportunity to make a representation against the proposed penalty.
- Article 311(3): where a question arises whether an inquiry is reasonably practicable, the decision of the authority empowered to dismiss, remove or reduce in rank is final; Tulsiram Patel (1985) held that this finality does not bind the courts.