Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(b) “If the power of judicial review of legislation and administrative actions is abrogated or taken away, the Constitution will cease to be what it is.” Critically evaluate.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically evaluate
The core of a good answer
Judicial review is the mechanism that makes a written, supreme Constitution enforceable; the Supreme Court has therefore treated it as part of the basic structure (Kesavananda 1973, Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain 1975, Minerva Mills 1980, L. Chandra Kumar 1997), though its exercise is itself limited by constitutional bars, restraint and questions of democratic legitimacy.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A critical evaluation should first establish why judicial review is essential to the identity of the Constitution, then test the claim against the limits on review and the criticism of judicial overreach, ending in a balanced judgement.
Answer outline
Introduction
Judicial review is the power of courts to test legislation and executive action against the Constitution and to declare them void if inconsistent. In India it rests on provisions including Articles 13, 32, 131 to 136, 143, 226 and 246.
Why the statement holds
- Without review, Part III would become mere exhortation: Article 13 makes laws inconsistent with fundamental rights void, and Article 32 is itself a fundamental right, described in the Constituent Assembly as "the very soul of the Constitution and the very heart of it".
- Federalism needs an umpire: under Article 131 the Supreme Court has original jurisdiction, to the exclusion of any other court, in disputes between the Government of India and States or between States.
- Kesavananda Bharati (1973) and Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) used review to check constitutional amendments; Minerva Mills (1980) struck down Sections 4 and 55 of the 42nd Amendment, which sought to oust review of amendments.
- L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997): the jurisdiction of the High Courts under Article 226 and of the Supreme Court under Article 32 is an integral and essential feature of the basic structure.
- I.R. Coelho (2007): laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after the Kesavananda decision of 24 April 1973 can be reviewed for infringing fundamental rights.
Limits and criticisms
- The Constitution itself bars courts in some areas: Article 122 (proceedings of Parliament cannot be questioned for irregularity of procedure), Article 74(2) (whether and what advice was tendered to the President), Article 329 (delimitation laws, and elections questioned only by election petition).
- Courts apply restraint, presumption of constitutionality and deference in economic policy.
- Critics see a counter-majoritarian difficulty and judicial overreach, for example in the striking down of the 99th Amendment and the NJAC in 2015 and in policy directions issued in PIL.
Conclusion
Removing judicial review would turn a supreme, limited Constitution into an ordinary statute; the right response to overreach is self-restraint, not abrogation.
Examples and data to cite
- Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (16 October 2015, 4:1) struck down the NJAC as an attempt to compromise the independence of the judiciary, contrary to the basic structure.
- S.P. Sampath Kumar v. Union of India ([1987] 1 SCC 124) treated administrative tribunals as a real substitute for the High Courts; a larger Bench revisited this in L. Chandra Kumar (1997).
Facts to remember
- In India judicial review is expressly provided for in the Constitution, through Articles 13, 32 and 226 among others.
- Waman Rao (1981): Ninth Schedule laws placed there before the Kesavananda decision (24 April 1973) cannot be challenged for violating fundamental rights.