“ ‘Constitutionalism’ connotes in essence—‘limited government’ or ‘a limitation on government’. It is the antithesis of arbitrary powers.” Discuss.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Constitutionalism is the idea that public power derives from and is limited by fundamental law; a document alone does not secure it, but rule of law, separation of powers, fundamental rights, judicial review, federalism and free elections do, and the Indian Supreme Court has protected these through the basic structure doctrine and the requirement that procedure be just, fair and reasonable.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks you to discuss the meaning of constitutionalism as limited government, distinguish it from merely having a constitution, identify the devices that limit power, and illustrate from Indian constitutional practice both its working and its threats.
Answer outline
Introduction
Constitutionalism is the belief that government authority derives from fundamental law and is limited by it, in contrast to rule by the arbitrary judgment or mere fiat of public officials. Its English antecedents go back to Magna Carta (1215); C.H. McIlwain's Constitutionalism: Ancient and Modern (1940) is a classic study of the idea.
Constitution and constitutionalism
- A constitution is the document or body of rules; constitutionalism is the commitment that those rules actually restrain rulers. As David Fellman observed, a state may have a written constitution, but it does not follow that it is committed to constitutionalism.
- Elements: supremacy of the constitution, rule of law, separation of powers, independent judiciary, guaranteed rights, periodic free elections, federal division of power, and an amendment procedure that is not unlimited.
Devices in the Indian Constitution
- Fundamental rights enforceable under Articles 32 and 226; Article 13 voids inconsistent laws.
- Division of power under Article 246 and the Seventh Schedule; independent institutions such as the Election Commission (Article 324) and the CAG (Article 148).
- Limited amending power: Kesavananda Bharati (1973) held that Article 368 cannot destroy the basic structure; Minerva Mills (1980) held limited amending power itself to be a basic feature.
Antithesis of arbitrariness
- Maneka Gandhi (1978): procedure must be just, fair and reasonable, not arbitrary or oppressive.
- S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (11 March 1994, nine judges): a proclamation under Article 356(1) is not immune from judicial review.
Stress tests
- The 1975 to 1977 Emergency, the 38th Amendment (which barred judicial review of emergency declarations), the 39th and 42nd Amendments and ADM Jabalpur (1976) showed how power can escape limits.
- The 44th Amendment (1978) sought to restore the pre-Emergency position; the Constitution now requires ‘armed rebellion’ instead of ‘internal disturbance’ and a written Cabinet decision for an emergency, and keeps Articles 20 and 21 enforceable during it.
Conclusion
Constitutionalism in India is sustained less by text than by institutions and a vigilant judiciary; its essence remains that every power is limited and answerable.
Examples and data to cite
- Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) struck down clause (4) of Article 329A, inserted by the 39th Amendment to shield the elections of the Prime Minister and Speaker from judicial review.
- I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007) held Ninth Schedule laws added after the Kesavananda decision open to review.
Facts to remember
- McIlwain published Constitutionalism: Ancient and Modern in 1940 (revised edition 1947).
- Kesavananda Bharati was decided on 24 April 1973 by a 13 judge bench by 7 to 6.
- The 44th Amendment was passed in 1978 to restore the Constitution to the condition it was in before the Emergency.