“The Legislature itself must set the essential policy, or lay down standards or policy in the Delegating Act and the delegate would then legislate to advance the legislative policy.” Elaborate the statement with the help of relevant case laws.
15 marks · directive: Elaborate
The core of a good answer
Indian courts allow delegated legislation but hold that the legislature cannot delegate its essential legislative function: it must itself lay down the policy, guidelines or standards, leaving the delegate to carry them out; delegation without such guidance is excessive and void, as the cases from In re Delhi Laws Act (1951) to Hamdard Dawakhana and Devi Das Gopal Krishan (1967) show, and as Gwalior Rayon (1973) reaffirmed.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Elaborate requires a full treatment of the doctrine of excessive delegation: why delegation is allowed, what the essential legislative function is, how courts look for policy and guidelines in the parent Act, and the leading cases on both sides.
Answer outline
Introduction
Delegated legislation is law made by the executive or another body under power conferred by a statute. The volume and technicality of modern legislation make it unavoidable, but the Constitution vests law-making in the legislature (Articles 245, 246), so limits are needed.
Foundation of the doctrine
- In re Delhi Laws Act (23 May 1951), a seven judge reference: the Court did not reach a single view, but the headnote records Mahajan J's opinion that a legislature cannot delegate its essential legislative functions, and Kania CJ distinguished true delegation from conditional legislation.
- Five judges upheld the power to extend laws with restrictions and modifications, but four judges held ultra vires the part allowing the executive to provide for the repeal or amendment of laws already in force.
Policy and guidelines test
- Harishankar Bagla v. State of M.P.: a control order under the Essential Supplies Act was upheld because the Act itself stated the policy of maintaining supplies and securing equitable distribution of essential commodities.
- Hamdard Dawakhana v. Union of India: clause (d) of Section 3 of the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Act was struck down because it conferred uncanalised power.
- Devi Das Gopal Krishan v. State of Punjab (1967): Section 5 of the East Punjab General Sales Tax Act, which let the government fix rates with no policy or guidance, was struck down as a ‘self-effacement of legislative power’.
- Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton Mills (1968): the majority upheld the delegation of taxing power to the municipal corporation, with Shah and Vaidialingam JJ dissenting.
- Gwalior Rayon v. Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax (21 December 1973): the majority (Khanna J) held that the legislature must lay down the guidelines, principles or policy, while Mathew J asked whether the legislature had abdicated its essential function or retained control.
Specific limits
- Rate-fixing in taxation can be delegated only where the legislature supplies guidance (Corporation of Calcutta v. Liberty Cinema, 1965, as summarised in Gwalior Rayon).
- Subordinate legislation can be struck down if it goes beyond the parent Act or the Constitution.
Conclusion
The statement captures the settled Indian test: delegation is valid only when the legislature has supplied the policy and the delegate merely carries it forward.
Examples and data to cite
- Sita Ram Bishambhar Dayal (1972), as summarised in Gwalior Rayon: rate-fixing is a legislative power but may be delegated if the legislature lays down policy and guidelines.
- Section 8(2)(b) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 was upheld in Gwalior Rayon because its policy (discouraging inter-State sales to unregistered dealers to prevent evasion) was clear.
Facts to remember
- Delegation is tested against Articles 245 and 246, which vest law-making in the legislatures.
- Conditional legislation, where the delegate decides when or where the law applies, was distinguished from true delegation by Kania CJ in In re Delhi Laws Act.