Keshavananda illustrates judicial creativity and the policy-making role of the Supreme Court of a very high order and could be regarded to be an improvement over the formulation in Golaknath. Examine with the help of relevant arguments.
20 marks · directive: Examine
The core of a good answer
Golaknath (1967) froze fundamental rights by treating amendments as ‘law’ under Article 13, which was rigid and invited confrontation; Kesavananda (1973) accepted Parliament's power to amend every provision but created, without textual basis, the limit of the basic structure, a creative and policy-laden move that better balanced flexibility with protection and has endured, though it is criticised for indeterminacy and judicial supremacy.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
‘Examine’ requires a close comparison of the two formulations, the reasoning used, and a judgement on whether Kesavananda improved on Golaknath. Arguments for and against should be presented, including how the doctrine has developed since.
Answer outline
Introduction
Early cases (Shankari Prasad 1951, Sajjan Singh 1965) upheld Parliament's power to amend any provision, including fundamental rights. Mudholkar J in Sajjan Singh first asked whether changing a ‘basic feature’ is merely an amendment.
Golaknath's formulation (1967)
- Eleven judges, 27 February 1967, majority of 6 to 5 led by Subba Rao CJ: Article 368 only lays down the procedure, the power coming from Entry 97 of List I; an amendment is ‘law’ under Article 13, so Parliament cannot take away or abridge fundamental rights.
- Applied prospective overruling: the 17th Amendment and other earlier amendments abridging fundamental rights remained valid.
- Weaknesses: denied any route to change Part III; hard to reconcile with the text of Article 368; Parliament responded with the 24th Amendment (1971).
Kesavananda's formulation (1973)
- Thirteen judges, 7 to 6, decided 24 April 1973: upheld the 24th Amendment, so amendments are outside Article 13, reversing Golaknath on that point.
- But the power to amend does not extend to damaging or destroying the basic structure; Khanna J's opinion, that Parliament has only a ‘power to amend’, was decisive.
- Upheld the 24th, 25th and 29th Amendments, with a partial exception for part of the 25th: the first part of Article 31C was upheld, but not the rest.
Judicial creativity and policy-making
- The doctrine is implied, not written; it reflects a choice to guard constitutional identity against majoritarian change.
- It allowed socio-economic reform (land reform laws, abridgment of property) while protecting the core.
- Its open texture gives the Court a continuing policy role in deciding what is basic.
Why it is an improvement
- Accepts the textual amending power, avoiding Golaknath's strained reading.
- Protects not just Part III but the whole constitutional identity, including democracy and judicial review.
- Flexible: amendments abridging rights are valid unless they damage the core.
- Tested and consolidated: Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975), Minerva Mills (1980), Waman Rao (1981), L. Chandra Kumar (1997), I.R. Coelho (2007), NJAC case (2015).
Criticisms
- Indeterminate and judge-made; counter-majoritarian.
- A narrow majority; the summary statement of the ‘view of the majority’ was signed by only nine of the thirteen judges.
- Shifts final constituent power from Parliament to the Court.
Conclusion
On balance Kesavananda is the more workable formulation: it trades Golaknath's rigid bar for a principled limit, and its survival for five decades shows its acceptance as part of constitutional practice.
Examples and data to cite
- Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980) struck down Sections 4 and 55 of the 42nd Amendment and held that a limited amending power is itself a basic feature.
- Waman Rao v. Union of India (1981) protected Ninth Schedule laws placed there before the Kesavananda decision of 24 April 1973.
- Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (16 October 2015) struck down the 99th Amendment (NJAC) as compromising judicial independence.
Facts to remember
- Kesavananda Bharati was heard by the largest bench in the Court's history, thirteen judges, from 31 October 1972 to 23 March 1973.
- Golaknath was decided on 27 February 1967 by eleven judges, 6 to 5.
- The 24th Amendment (1971) amended Articles 13 and 368, inserting Article 13(4), so that amendments under Article 368 are outside the bar of Article 13.