“It is the satisfaction of the President and not of the Central Cabinet, for proclamation of emergency in India.” Do you agree with it? Critically examine and also, discuss about the consequences of such proclamation.
15 marks · directive: Critically examine; Discuss
The core of a good answer
The statement is correct only in form: Article 352(1) speaks of the President's satisfaction, but under Article 74(1) the President acts in accordance with ministerial advice and Article 352(3) bars a proclamation unless the Union Cabinet's decision is communicated to him in writing, so the satisfaction is in substance that of the Cabinet; the proclamation then centralises legislative, executive and financial power and restricts fundamental rights.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The first part asks whether you agree, so a clear position is needed, backed by the text of Articles 74 and 352 and case law. The second part asks for the legal consequences of a proclamation under Article 352.
Answer outline
Introduction
Article 352(1) allows the President, if satisfied that a grave emergency exists threatening the security of India or any part by war, external aggression or armed rebellion, to proclaim an emergency.
Whose satisfaction
- Shamsher Singh v. State of Punjab (1974): the satisfaction of the President is not his personal satisfaction but the satisfaction of his Council of Ministers.
- Article 74(1): the 42nd Amendment (1976) stipulated that the President shall act in accordance with the advice of the Council of Ministers; the present proviso lets him require the Council to reconsider its advice, after which he must act on the advice given after reconsideration.
- Article 352(3): the President shall not issue the proclamation unless the decision of the Union Cabinet that it may be issued has been communicated to him in writing; the 1975 proclamation had been issued on the Prime Minister's advice without discussion in the Union Cabinet, which ratified it the next morning.
- Hence the statement does not reflect the constitutional position; the President's personal role is limited to requiring reconsideration of the advice.
Checks on the proclamation
- Approval by both Houses within one month, each resolution needing a majority of total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting (Article 352(4), (6)).
- Continues for six months at a time with fresh approval (Article 352(5)).
- The Lok Sabha can disapprove by resolution, after which the President must revoke the proclamation, and one-tenth of its total members can require a special sitting within 14 days of notice (Article 352(7), (8)).
- The 38th Amendment (1975) had barred judicial review of emergency declarations; in S.R. Bommai (1994) a proclamation under Article 356(1) was held not immune from judicial review.
Consequences
- Executive: the Union may give directions to any State on the manner of exercising its executive power (Article 353(a)).
- Legislative: Parliament may legislate on State List matters (Article 250) and confer powers and impose duties on Union officers even on matters outside the Union List (Article 353(b)).
- Financial: the President may by order modify the distribution of revenues under Articles 268 to 279, until the end of the financial year in which the emergency ends (Article 354).
- Fundamental rights: Article 19 is suspended automatically only for an emergency on grounds of war or external aggression (Article 358); enforcement of other rights may be suspended by order under Article 359, except Articles 20 and 21.
- Term of the Lok Sabha may be extended by law one year at a time, not beyond six months after the proclamation ceases (proviso to Article 83(2)).
Conclusion
As the Constitution now stands the decision is formally the President's but substantively the Cabinet's, and the consequences, though drastic, are hedged by parliamentary and judicial checks.
Examples and data to cite
- The proclamation of 25 June 1975, issued on the Prime Minister's advice, lasted until 21 March 1977.
- S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (11 March 1994, nine judges) held that a proclamation under Article 356(1) is not immune from judicial review.
Facts to remember
- The 1950 text of Article 352(1) used ‘internal disturbance’; the present text uses ‘armed rebellion’.
- A proclamation can cover the whole or any part of India and, under the Explanation, can be made before actual war, aggression or rebellion if the danger is imminent.
- Article 352(9) allows different proclamations on different grounds even while another proclamation is in operation.