Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Whether International Law is a law in the true sense of the term ‘law’ or not? Examine.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Examine
The core of a good answer
International law is law in the true sense: it is a body of rules that States accept as binding, it has recognised sources, it is applied by courts and it carries sanctions, even though it lacks a single legislature and a centralised enforcing authority.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question revives the debate opened by Austin's command theory of law. 'Examine' needs both sides: the command theory objection and its weaknesses, then the modern view based on acceptance, sources, adjudication and practice, ending with a balanced verdict.
Answer outline
Introduction
Whether international law is 'law' depends on the definition of law adopted: a sovereign's command backed by sanction (Austin) or a law between sovereign and equal States based on their common consent (Oppenheim).
Arguments that it is not true law
- John Austin: law is a command of a sovereign backed by the threat of sanction; international law has no sovereign power to enforce it, so it is only 'positive morality'.
- No legislature: rules come from treaties and custom, which depend on the consent of States.
- No compulsory adjudication: the ICJ hears cases the parties refer to it, or where they have accepted its jurisdiction by treaty or by a declaration under Article 36(2) of its Statute.
- Weak enforcement: powerful States can ignore rulings, and Security Council action under Chapter VII can be blocked by a permanent member's veto.
Arguments that it is law
- Law does not need a sovereign: H.L.A. Hart's The Concept of Law rejected Austin's command theory, likening it to the orders of a gunman in a bank; obligation does not rest on threats alone.
- Recognised sources: Article 38(1) of the ICJ Statute lists treaties, custom, general principles of law, and judicial decisions and teachings as a subsidiary means.
- States treat it as law: they justify conduct in legal terms rather than deny the rule; pacta sunt servanda is written into Article 26 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969.
- Sanctions exist: Security Council decisions binding under Article 25, measures under Articles 41 and 42, countermeasures, diplomatic and economic pressure, and reputational costs.
- Courts apply it as law: the ICJ, ITLOS, the ICC, WTO panels and national courts.
Indian and practical angle
- Article 51 of the Constitution of India, a Directive Principle, asks the State to promote international peace and security and to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations.
- Most rules (diplomatic immunity, law of the sea, aviation, trade) are observed routinely; breaches attract attention because they are exceptional.
Conclusion
International law is a weaker but genuine legal order; its defects are those of a decentralised system still developing institutions, not proof that it is not law.
Examples and data to cite
- Nicaragua v United States (ICJ, 27 June 1986): the Court found the United States in breach of its customary obligation not to use force against another State; the United States refused to comply and vetoed enforcement in the Security Council, showing the enforcement gap.
- Security Council Resolution 678 (29 November 1990) authorised States to use 'all necessary means' to remove Iraqi forces from Kuwait after 15 January 1991, an example of collective enforcement.
- Jadhav case (India v Pakistan, ICJ, 17 July 2019): Pakistan was found in breach of its obligations on consular access and directed to provide it.
Facts to remember
- Austin called international law 'positive morality', not law properly so called.
- Article 38(1) of the Statute of the ICJ lists the sources the Court applies.
- Under Article 25 of the UN Charter Members agree to accept and carry out the decisions of the Security Council.
- Article 51 of the Constitution of India is a Directive Principle that includes respect for international law and treaty obligations.
- Article 26 VCLT 1969: every treaty in force is binding upon the parties and must be performed by them in good faith.