Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Critically examine the theories which have been propounded to explain the relationship between International Law and Municipal Law.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
Monism treats international and municipal law as one legal order, and dualism treats them as two separate orders so that international rules bind domestically only after being made national law; actual State practice, including India's, mixes the two, while on the international plane a State cannot plead its own law to escape an obligation.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the main theories on the relationship, their proponents and logic, and a critical appraisal: how far each explains real State practice and judicial decisions. India's constitutional position should be shown.
Answer outline
Introduction
The relationship decides whether a treaty or custom can be applied by national courts, and which prevails in a conflict.
Monism
- International and national law are part of the same legal order. Hans Kelsen's pure theory traces the validity of every norm, through a hierarchy, to a presupposed basic norm (Grundnorm), and treats international law as similarly hierarchical.
- Consequence: in pure monism a national rule that conflicts with international law is null and void, even if it post-dates the international rule; in the Netherlands a judge must apply international law even if it is not in conformity with Dutch law.
- Criticism: monist judges may be unfamiliar with international law and can misapply it, so monism does not by itself secure compliance.
Dualism
- Associated with Heinrich Triepel, with Dionisio Anzilotti as one of its main proponents: national and international law are two separate legal orders, and national judges apply international law only once it has been translated into national law.
- Consequence: a treaty has no domestic effect until transformed by legislation; the United Kingdom is the classic dualist example for treaties.
- Criticism: dualism gives no shield on the international plane, because a party may not invoke its internal law as justification for failing to perform a treaty (Article 27, Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969).
Transformation as a question of national law
- Whether an international rule must be transformed into national law before it binds domestically is a question of national, not of international law; that is why the same treaty may apply directly in one State and need legislation in another.
Indian position
- Article 51 of the Constitution, a Directive Principle, asks the State to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations.
- Vishaka v State of Rajasthan (1997): with no domestic law occupying the field of workplace sexual harassment, the Supreme Court held international conventions and norms significant for interpreting the constitutional guarantees and laid down guidelines that applied until a law took effect on 23 April 2013.
Conclusion
No single theory fits practice; international law prevails on the international plane (a State cannot plead its law to avoid an obligation), while on the domestic plane each State's own law decides how international law takes effect.
Examples and data to cite
- Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969: a party may not invoke its internal law as justification for failure to perform a treaty.
- Medellín v Texas (US Supreme Court, 2008): some treaties are not self-executing and need implementing legislation.
- Vishaka v State of Rajasthan (1997): guidelines on sexual harassment at the workplace, framed with the help of international conventions in the absence of a domestic law.
Facts to remember
- Monism: one legal order; dualism: two separate orders.
- Anzilotti was one of the main proponents of Triepel's theory of dualism.
- Article 51 of the Constitution of India includes respect for international law and treaty obligations among the Directive Principles.
- In the United Kingdom a treaty has no effect in municipal law until an Act of Parliament gives effect to it.