Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
What do you mean by imposing ‘Double Veto’ by a permanent member of the Security Council of the United Nations? Also, discuss its impact on decision-making process of the United Nations.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
A double veto is the use of the veto twice in one matter: first on the preliminary question whether the matter is procedural (so that it is treated as non-procedural), and then on the substance; it lets one permanent member block even procedural steps and has weakened Security Council decision-making.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the meaning of the double veto, its basis in Article 27 and the 1945 San Francisco Statement, and its effect on how the UN decides, including the checks that have grown around the veto.
Answer outline
Introduction
Article 27 of the UN Charter makes procedural decisions need nine affirmative votes, while all other decisions need nine votes including the concurring votes of the permanent members; the Charter does not say who decides whether a matter is procedural.
Meaning and mechanism
- The statement of the four sponsoring governments at San Francisco (8 June 1945) set out their understanding of Council voting, which is the source of the view that the preliminary question whether a matter is procedural can itself be vetoed.
- Step 1: a vote on whether the issue is procedural; a permanent member votes no, so the preliminary question is treated as non-procedural. Step 2: the same member vetoes the substantive proposal.
- Result: a permanent member can turn even a procedural question (such as setting up a sub-committee or placing an item on the agenda) into one it can block.
Practice
- The permissibility of a double veto has never been resolved; the permanent members later reached an informal agreement to avoid it, and it has not been used since 1959.
Impact on UN decision-making
- Paralysis: a single member could stall inquiries and procedural steps, deepening Cold War deadlock in the Council.
- Shift to the General Assembly: Uniting for Peace resolution 377 A (V) of 3 November 1950 lets the Assembly meet in emergency special session when the Council fails because of lack of unanimity of permanent members.
- Narrowing of the veto: in practice a permanent member's abstention or absence does not count as a veto.
- Accountability: a General Assembly resolution of 26 April 2022 mandates a debate in the Assembly whenever a veto is cast.
Conclusion
The double veto magnifies the privilege of the permanent members beyond what Article 27 plainly gives; its disuse and the growth of procedural checks show that UN practice has tried to confine the veto to substantive matters.
Examples and data to cite
- San Francisco Statement of the four sponsoring governments, 8 June 1945, on voting procedure.
- Uniting for Peace resolution 377 A (V), 3 November 1950; used in 1956 to help resolve the Suez Crisis.
- General Assembly resolution of 26 April 2022 mandating a debate when a veto is cast.
Facts to remember
- Article 27(2): procedural matters by affirmative vote of nine members.
- Article 27(3): other matters by nine votes including the concurring votes of the permanent members; a party to a dispute abstains in decisions under Chapter VI and Article 52(3).
- The word 'veto' does not appear in the Charter.
- A permanent member's abstention is not treated as a veto.