“The present world economic order is supposed to be guided by the operation of free market forces propelled by free competition, based on free movement of goods and services including technology.” Discuss the role of the principle of non-discrimination and free trade under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in this regard.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
GATT built the free market trading order on two legs: non-discrimination (most favoured nation treatment under Article I and national treatment under Article III) and progressive liberalisation (tariff bindings and the ban on quantitative restrictions), tempered by exceptions and special treatment for developing countries and later widened by the WTO to services.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks how GATT's core principles give legal shape to a market-driven world economic order. A good answer explains the principles with Articles, the exceptions, the WTO extension to services, and a critical view from the standpoint of developing countries such as India.
Answer outline
Introduction
GATT was signed at Geneva on 30 October 1947 by 23 countries, including India, and applied provisionally from 1 January 1948; it continued as the trade framework when the Havana Charter for an International Trade Organization was never ratified.
Non-discrimination
- Most favoured nation (Article I): any advantage given to one contracting party must be extended immediately and unconditionally to all; prevents trade blocs based on preference and lets small economies share concessions.
- National treatment (Article III): imported goods, once inside, must not be taxed or regulated less favourably than like domestic goods; prevents hidden protection.
- Non-discriminatory administration of quantitative restrictions (Article XIII).
Free trade and liberalisation
- Tariff concessions bound in schedules (Article II); tariffs are the only accepted form of protection.
- General elimination of quantitative restrictions (Article XI).
- Successive rounds lowered tariffs: Kennedy Round (1964 to 1967), Tokyo Round (from 1973, covering non-tariff measures and framework agreements), Uruguay Round (from 1986) ending with the Marrakesh Agreement of 15 April 1994 and the WTO from 1 January 1995.
- Transparency (Article X: publication and administration of trade regulations) and dispute settlement through consultation and nullification or impairment (Articles XXII and XXIII).
Exceptions and balance
- Customs unions and free trade areas (Article XXIV); balance of payments measures (Articles XII and XVIII:B); safeguards (Article XIX); general exceptions for health, conservation and public morals (Article XX); security (Article XXI).
- Development dimension: Article XVIII (special and differential treatment) and Part IV on Trade and Development, adopted during the Kennedy Round, which freed developing countries from the demand for reciprocity.
Goods, services and technology under the WTO
- The Uruguay Round extended the multilateral system beyond goods, notably through the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS).
Critical view
- Free trade between unequal partners can entrench inequality; developing countries, through UNCTAD (from 1964) and the Group of 77, pressed for a New International Economic Order (1974), including a just relationship between the prices of their raw materials and those of goods they import.
- Agricultural subsidies of developed countries, non-tariff barriers, the spread of preferential agreements outside MFN, and an Appellate Body left without members (the last member's term expired on 30 November 2020) weaken the system.
Conclusion
Non-discrimination and liberalisation remain the legal core of a market-based trading order; their legitimacy depends on fair exceptions, special treatment for developing countries and a working dispute settlement system.
Examples and data to cite
- India: Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products (WTO DS90): the Appellate Body report of 23 August 1999 upheld the panel's finding that the restrictions breached GATT Articles XI and XVIII:11; India removed the restrictions on the remaining 715 items with effect from 1 April 2001.
- United States: Import Prohibition of Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products (Appellate Body report, 12 October 1998): the measure was provisionally justified under Article XX(g) but failed the requirements of the chapeau of Article XX.
- Marrakesh Agreement establishing the WTO, 15 April 1994.
- WTO Appellate Body unable to review appeals because of vacancies; the term of its last sitting member expired on 30 November 2020.
Facts to remember
- GATT signed 30 October 1947; provisionally applied from 1 January 1948; 23 original contracting parties.
- Article I: MFN; Article III: national treatment; Article XI: elimination of quantitative restrictions; Article XXIV: regional arrangements; Article XX: general exceptions.
- Havana Charter of the ITO (March 1948) was not ratified by the United States Senate, so the ITO never came into existence.
- GATT 1994 is part of the WTO Agreements; the WTO began on 1 January 1995.