“International Law may be defined as that body of law which is composed for its greater part of the principles and rules of conduct which States feel themselves bound to observe and, therefore, do commonly observe in their relation to each other.” Explain.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
The definition explains international law by States' sense of obligation (opinio juris) and their actual practice; its words 'for its greater part' leave room for the rules on international organisations and individuals that modern international law also contains.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question wants the definition unpacked: its elements, its basis in consent and custom, how it improves on the older State-only definitions, and its limits in the light of newer subjects of international law.
Answer outline
Introduction
The definition rests international law on two things: the sense of obligation States feel, and the conduct they actually follow; both are the ingredients of customary law under Article 38(1)(b) of the ICJ Statute.
Elements of the definition
- 'Body of law': a system of legal rules, not mere morality or comity.
- 'Principles and rules of conduct': both general principles (sovereign equality, pacta sunt servanda, good faith) and specific rules (diplomatic immunity, law of the sea).
- 'States feel themselves bound to observe': the psychological element, opinio juris sive necessitatis, which turns practice into custom.
- 'And, therefore, do commonly observe': the material element, general and consistent State practice; observance follows from the sense of obligation.
- 'In their relation to each other': the classical inter-State scope.
Why 'for its greater part'
- States are the principal but not the only subjects. Reparation for Injuries advisory opinion (1949): the UN has international legal personality.
- Individuals have rights and duties: under the Nuremberg Principles a person who commits a crime under international law is responsible and liable to punishment, and the Rome Statute of the ICC (adopted 17 July 1998, in force 1 July 2002) covers genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression.
- LaGrand (ICJ, 27 June 2001) held that the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations 1963 grants rights to individuals.
Comparison with other definitions
- Oppenheim: international law is a law between sovereign and equal States based on the common consent of these States; a purely State-centred view.
- The quoted definition keeps the State basis, but its words 'for its greater part' leave room for international organisations and individuals, so it suits modern conditions better.
Critical points
- Observance is not universal; breaches of the use of force rule occur, yet States still justify their conduct in legal terms.
- The definition rests on consent and practice and is less suited to peremptory norms (jus cogens, Article 53 VCLT 1969) which bind regardless of consent.
Conclusion
The definition captures why States obey international law (a felt obligation) and how it exists (common observance), while its extension to institutions and individuals reflects international law's growth beyond inter-State relations.
Examples and data to cite
- Asylum case (ICJ, 20 November 1950): a custom must be shown to be continuously and uniformly executed.
- S.S. Lotus (PCIJ, 1927): the Court found no rule of international law prohibiting Turkey's prosecution; the 'Lotus principle' that States may act unless a prohibition applies reflects the consent basis of the definition.
- Reparation for Injuries advisory opinion (ICJ, 1949) on UN legal personality.
- Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court adopted on 17 July 1998.
Facts to remember
- Opinio juris and State practice are the two elements of customary international law.
- Article 38(1)(b) of the ICJ Statute: international custom as evidence of a general practice accepted as law.
- Article 53 VCLT 1969 defines a peremptory norm (jus cogens).
- Subjects of international law today include States, international organisations and, for some purposes, individuals.