Discuss the facts and the Principles of the Law of the Sea, emerged in ‘Corfu Channel Case’, with reference to the territorial sea and contiguous zone. Give your opinion, how far the ‘Strait of Hormuz’ problem could be resolved under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982) in the light of the principle of ‘innocent passage’ by foreign vessels. Explain.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The Corfu Channel case (ICJ, 1949) established that foreign ships, including warships, have a right of innocent passage in peacetime through straits used for international navigation which the coastal State may regulate but not suspend or subject to prior authorisation, and that a coastal State must warn of known dangers; UNCLOS 1982 strengthens this with non-suspendable transit passage, but the Hormuz problem is only partly resolvable because Iran has not ratified UNCLOS, the 2026 closure arises in armed conflict, and there is no compulsory forum.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two parts: the facts and principles of Corfu Channel related to the territorial sea and contiguous zone; then a reasoned opinion on applying UNCLOS innocent and transit passage to the Strait of Hormuz, including its legal limits.
Answer outline
Introduction
Parts of the Corfu Channel lie within Albanian territorial waters; the dispute was the first case of any type heard by the ICJ.
Facts
- 15 May 1946: Albanian shore batteries fired at the British cruisers Orion and Superb passing the channel; neither was hit.
- 22 October 1946: a British squadron (cruisers Mauritius and Leander, destroyers Saumarez and Volage) passed through; Saumarez and then Volage struck mines in Albanian waters; 44 persons died.
- 12 and 13 November 1946: the Royal Navy swept the channel without Albania's consent (Operation Retail).
- Judgments: preliminary objection 25 March 1948; merits 9 April 1949; compensation of £843,947 fixed on 15 December 1949.
Principles laid down
- Straits used for international navigation between two parts of the high seas carry a right of innocent passage for warships and merchant ships in peacetime; the test is geographical situation and use for international navigation.
- The coastal State may regulate passage but cannot require prior authorisation or prohibit it.
- The Court found that the United Kingdom had exercised the right of innocent passage through an international strait, although its ships were at action stations.
- Albania must have known of the minefield and had a responsibility to notify other States of the danger; every State is obliged not to knowingly allow its territory to be used for acts against the rights of other States.
- Operation Retail violated Albanian sovereignty because it was carried out against the will of the Albanian Government; the Court rejected the British plea of intervention and self-help.
Territorial sea and contiguous zone
- Territorial sea up to 12 nautical miles (Article 3 UNCLOS) is under sovereignty subject to innocent passage (Articles 17 to 19); passage is innocent so long as not prejudicial to peace, good order or security, with a list of non-innocent acts in Article 19(2).
- Coastal State may suspend innocent passage temporarily in specified areas for security (Article 25(3)), but not in international straits (Article 45(2)), codifying Corfu (earlier Article 16(4) of the 1958 Geneva Convention).
- Contiguous zone up to 24 nautical miles (Article 33): control only to prevent and punish breaches of customs, fiscal, immigration or sanitary laws; it gives no right to close navigation.
Applying this to Hormuz
- About 21 nautical miles wide at its narrowest, so the 12 nautical mile territorial seas of Iran and Oman together can cover it; it is a strait used for international navigation, and about 25 per cent of seaborne oil trade passed through it each year in 2023 to 2025.
- UNCLOS Part III gives transit passage (Articles 37 and 38) which cannot be impeded or suspended (Article 44); ships must proceed without delay and refrain from threat of force (Article 39); traffic separation schemes under Article 41.
- Limits: Iran signed UNCLOS in 1982 but has not ratified; on signing it declared that transit passage benefits only States parties, and its 1993 law requires prior permission for warships. Oman ratified in 1989 but also requires permission for warships. The United States has not ratified but claims these rights as custom.
- Even so, the right of innocent passage through straits recognised in Corfu Channel was found by the Court in 1949, before UNCLOS, so it does not depend on Iran ratifying the Convention.
- During the 2026 Iran War the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps broadcast from 28 February 2026 that passage was 'not allowed', confirmed the strait closed on 2 March 2026, and about a dozen mines were reported laid by 12 March 2026; Corfu's duty to warn shipping of mines is directly relevant.
- No compulsory forum: UNCLOS Part XV dispute settlement binds only parties, so resolution depends on diplomacy, the Security Council or a special agreement to go to the ICJ.
Conclusion
UNCLOS and Corfu Channel give a clear legal answer that the strait must remain open to passage, but the law alone cannot resolve the Hormuz problem; its enforcement depends on wider ratification, political settlement and collective action.
Examples and data to cite
- Corfu Channel case (United Kingdom v Albania), ICJ, merits judgment 9 April 1949; compensation £843,947 on 15 December 1949.
- Iran seized the British-flagged tanker Stena Impero in the strait in July 2019.
- Geneva Convention on the Territorial Sea and the Contiguous Zone 1958, Article 16(4), codified the non-suspendable innocent passage through straits.
- Oman ratified UNCLOS in 1989; Iran has signed but not ratified.
Facts to remember
- UNCLOS: territorial sea 12 nm (Article 3); contiguous zone 24 nm (Article 33); innocent passage Articles 17 to 19; transit passage Articles 37 to 44.
- Article 44: no suspension of transit passage; Article 45(2): no suspension of innocent passage in straits.
- Corfu Channel: duty of a State not to allow knowingly its territory to be used for acts contrary to the rights of other States.
- UNCLOS was opened for signature on 10 December 1982 at Montego Bay and entered into force on 16 November 1994.