Discuss the composition, powers and functions of the Security Council of the United Nations for the maintenance of international peace and security.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The Security Council of 15 members, five permanent with the veto, holds primary responsibility for international peace and security (Article 24) and can bind all Members (Article 25), acting through pacific settlement under Chapter VI and enforcement under Chapter VII, besides electoral, admission and judicial-enforcement functions.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question needs a structured account of composition and voting, and of powers and functions under the Charter chapters, with examples of their use and a brief note on limits and reform.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Security Council is the principal organ to which Members confer primary responsibility for maintaining international peace and security, so that the UN can act promptly and effectively.
Composition and voting
- Article 23: 15 members; permanent members China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States; ten non-permanent members elected by the General Assembly for two years, five each year, not eligible for immediate re-election.
- Enlarged only once, in 1965, when non-permanent seats rose from six to ten, making 15 members.
- Article 27: procedural decisions by nine affirmative votes; other decisions need nine votes including concurring votes of the permanent members (the veto); a party to a dispute abstains under Chapter VI.
- Non-members may take part without vote in discussions affecting them (Articles 31 and 32).
Primary responsibility and binding decisions
- Article 24: Members confer primary responsibility and agree that the Council acts on their behalf.
- Article 25: Members agree to accept and carry out its decisions; Article 103 gives Charter obligations priority over other treaties.
Pacific settlement (Chapter VI)
- May investigate any dispute or situation (Article 34), call on parties to settle by peaceful means (Article 33) and recommend procedures or terms of settlement (Articles 36 and 37).
Enforcement (Chapter VII)
- Article 39: determines the existence of a threat to the peace, breach of the peace or act of aggression.
- Article 40: provisional measures; Article 41: measures not involving armed force such as sanctions and severance of relations; Article 42: action by air, sea or land forces.
- Articles 43 to 47: agreements on forces and the Military Staff Committee; the Committee was stalled by Cold War divisions and largely stopped working in the mid-1950s, so in practice the Council authorises Member States to act.
- Article 51: Members must report self-defence measures to the Council; Chapter VIII (Article 53): enforcement by regional arrangements needs its authorisation.
Other functions
- Recommends admission of Members, and suspension or expulsion (Articles 4 to 6); recommends the appointment of the Secretary-General (Article 97).
- May recommend or decide measures to give effect to an ICJ judgment that a party fails to perform (Article 94(2)).
- Creates subsidiary organs (Article 29): peacekeeping missions, sanctions committees, criminal tribunals.
Conclusion
The Council has wide and binding powers, but their use depends on agreement among the permanent members; reform of composition and the veto, sought by India among others, is central to its legitimacy.
Examples and data to cite
- Resolution 678 (29 November 1990) authorised Member States to use 'all necessary means' to remove Iraqi forces from Kuwait.
- The Council created the ad hoc tribunals for the former Yugoslavia (1993) and Rwanda (1994) under Chapter VII.
- Resolution 1373, adopted on 28 September 2001 after the 11 September attacks, established the Counter-Terrorism Committee.
- Korea, 1950: Resolutions 83 (27 June) and 84 (7 July) authorised assistance to South Korea while the Soviet Union was boycotting the Council and so could not veto them.
Facts to remember
- Article 23: 15 members; non-permanent members elected for two years.
- Article 24: primary responsibility; Article 25: binding decisions.
- Articles 39, 41, 42 form the core of Chapter VII enforcement.
- The Council has been enlarged only once (1965); India is part of the G4 (Brazil, Germany, India, Japan) seeking permanent seats.