Define the term ‘nationality’. State the various modes of acquisition of nationality by a person. Differentiate between ‘nationality’ and ‘domicile’.
15 marks · directive: Differentiate
The core of a good answer
Nationality is the legal bond between an individual and a State that makes the person a member of it, with reciprocal rights and duties; it is acquired by birth (jus soli), descent (jus sanguinis), registration (for example on marriage to a national), naturalisation and incorporation of territory; it differs from domicile, which is the place of a person's permanent home and determines civil status in private international law.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Three tasks: a definition (with Nottebohm's genuine link), the modes of acquisition (with Indian law as illustration) and a point-by-point distinction from domicile.
Answer outline
Introduction
Nationality is the legal bond between a person and a State; in Nottebohm (1955) the ICJ upheld the principle of effective nationality, requiring a genuine link between the person and the State.
Nationality in international law
- Nationality is conferred by each State's own law, but on the international plane a nationality without a genuine link need not be accepted by another State for the purpose of diplomatic protection.
- Nottebohm (Liechtenstein v Guatemala, 6 April 1955): the claim was inadmissible because Nottebohm's naturalisation lacked a genuine link with Liechtenstein, so Liechtenstein was 'not entitled to extend its protection to Nottebohm vis-à-vis Guatemala'.
- Importance: diplomatic protection, jurisdiction, duty of allegiance, right of entry; Article 15 UDHR gives everyone the right to a nationality.
Modes of acquisition
- By birth: jus soli (place of birth) or jus sanguinis (nationality of parents).
- Naturalisation: on application after residence and other conditions.
- Registration: for specified categories, in India for example persons married to a citizen, minor children of citizens and persons of Indian origin, after 12 months' residence.
- Incorporation of territory: residents of Goa, Daman and Diu became Indian citizens on 20 December 1961 unless they declared otherwise.
- India: the Citizenship Act 1955 provides for citizenship by birth (restricted by parents' status since 1987 and 2004), descent (section 4), registration and naturalisation (generally 11 of the previous 14 years of residence plus the last 12 months); the constitutional provisions took effect on 26 November 1949 for persons domiciled in India.
Nationality and domicile distinguished
- Nature: nationality is a political and public law bond with a State; domicile is a civil law connection with a territorial legal system.
- Purpose: nationality governs allegiance, diplomatic protection and political rights; domicile governs personal law matters such as succession, marriage and capacity in private international law.
- Number: a person may have two nationalities or none (statelessness); a person always has one domicile and only one at a time.
- Basis: nationality depends on the State's law and grant; a domicile of choice depends on residence in fact in a new place plus the intention of permanently settling there, while the domicile of origin comes from a parent at birth (in Udny v Udny, Udny kept a Scottish domicile of origin though born and living in Tuscany).
- Change: nationality changes with State consent; domicile of choice is acquired by the person's own act.
Conclusion
Nationality links the individual to the international legal order through the State, while domicile links the individual to a legal system for private law purposes; the two often coincide but are legally independent.
Examples and data to cite
- Nottebohm case (ICJ, 6 April 1955) on the genuine link requirement.
- Udny v Udny: domicile of origin is set by the parent's domicile, not by the place of birth.
- Citizenship Act 1955 on acquisition of Indian citizenship by birth, descent, registration and naturalisation.
Facts to remember
- Article 15 UDHR: everyone has the right to a nationality; no one shall be arbitrarily deprived of it.
- Jus soli and jus sanguinis are the two bases of nationality by birth.
- Domicile of choice = residence in fact plus the intention of permanently settling; a person has only one domicile at any time and never none.