"'Vicarious liability' is based on public policy rather than fault." Critically analyse the above statement in the light of decided cases.
20 marks · directive: Critically analyse
The core of a good answer
Vicarious liability makes one person answerable for another's tort without any fault of his own, so its justification lies in policy (enterprise risk, the employer's ability to compensate, deterrence) rather than blame; yet it is not unlimited, because the employee's own tort and a sufficient connection between the employment and the wrong must still be proved.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The candidate must explain the basis of vicarious liability, show through cases that the employer's own fault is irrelevant, and then critically test the statement: the doctrine is policy-driven, but its limits (the relationship, the course of employment and the close connection test) restrain pure policy.
Answer outline
Introduction
Vicarious liability is liability for the tort of another arising from a relationship, typically employer and employee or principal and agent; the maxims are respondeat superior and qui facit per alium facit per se.
Not based on the employer's fault
- The employer is liable even though he was careful in selecting and supervising the employee.
- Limpus v London General Omnibus Co (1862): a driver who, against express prohibitions, pulled in front of a rival omnibus to obstruct it was doing his job of driving in an unauthorised mode; the employer was liable.
- Lloyd v Grace, Smith and Co (1912): the employer was liable for an employee's fraud even though the fraud did not benefit the employer.
- Century Insurance Co v Northern Ireland Road Transport Board (1942): an employee who carelessly threw away a match while delivering petrol and set a petrol station alight was acting in the course of his employment.
- Rose v Plenty (1976): a milkman who took a boy to help on his round against orders was acting in furtherance of the employer's business, so the employer was liable for the boy's injury.
Policy reasons and the modern test
- Various Claimants v Catholic Child Welfare Society (2012): the UK Supreme Court emphasised enterprise risk, that the employer who creates a risk through his business should bear its cost.
- Lister v Hesley Hall Ltd (2001): the House of Lords held the employer liable for a boarding-house warden's sexual abuse of boys, because the connection between the employment and the torts was very close.
- Mohamud v WM Morrison Supermarkets (2016): Lord Toulson framed a two-stage test: what field of activities was entrusted to the employee, and whether there was sufficient connection between that position and the wrongful conduct.
- Courts use control, organisation and sufficient relationship tests to decide whether the relationship can give rise to vicarious liability.
Where limits remain
- There must be a primary tort by the employee; the employer is liable only for that wrong, and the employee remains jointly liable.
- Beard v London General Omnibus Co (1900): a conductor who drove the bus was acting completely outside his duties, so the employer was not liable.
- WM Morrison Supermarkets v Various Claimants (2020): a senior auditor leaked data of about 126,000 employees online to pursue a personal vendetta; he was not furthering his employer's business, so Morrisons was not liable.
- An employer is generally not liable for an independent contractor, so the line between employee and contractor matters.
- Lister v Romford Ice and Cold Storage Co Ltd (1957): the employer may seek indemnity from the negligent employee, showing that the employee's fault still counts.
Conclusion
The statement is largely correct: vicarious liability is a deliberate allocation of loss on grounds of social policy, but courts keep it within principled limits of relationship, a primary wrong and close connection, so the employee's fault and policy work together.
Examples and data to cite
- Limpus v London General Omnibus Co (1862)
- Lloyd v Grace, Smith and Co (1912)
- Lister v Hesley Hall Ltd (2001)
- Mohamud v WM Morrison Supermarkets (2016)
- WM Morrison Supermarkets v Various Claimants (2020)
- Beard v London General Omnibus Co (1900)
Facts to remember
- Maxims: respondeat superior; qui facit per alium facit per se.
- Two-stage test (Mohamud, 2016): field of activities entrusted, and sufficient connection between the position and the wrongful conduct.
- Employer is generally not liable for torts of an independent contractor.
- The employee remains jointly liable; the employer may seek indemnity (Lister v Romford Ice).