'X', a 25-year-old boy, makes a promise to 'Y', an 18-year-old girl, that he will marry her if she has 'carnal-relations' with him. The girl is reluctant, but agrees after repeated assurances from the boy that he will marry her. Fifteen days after the act, the boy sends her a text message stating that he cannot keep his promise because marriage with her does not align with his career plans and that he needs to marry an NRI girl to facilitate his settlement abroad. What offence, if any, has been committed by the boy ? Discuss. In this context, explain the provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in the light of amendments relating to sexual offences, which recently took place.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
If it is shown that X never intended to marry Y when he made the promise and used it only to overcome her reluctance, he commits the offence under s.69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (sexual intercourse by making a promise to marry without any intention of fulfilling it, not amounting to rape; imprisonment up to ten years and fine); if he intended to marry at the time and later changed his mind, it is a breach of promise and not this offence.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A problem question: identify the issue (consent obtained by a promise to marry), apply the statutory provisions and the test they set (a promise made without intention to fulfil it, as against a later change of mind), reach a reasoned conclusion on the facts, and then explain the BNS framework on sexual offences and how it changed the earlier law.
Answer outline
Introduction
Y is an adult, so the question is whether her consent, given because of X's repeated assurances, was valid consent or was obtained by deceit. Under the general rule in BNS s.28, consent given under a misconception of fact, where the doer knows of it, is not consent; the BNS now also has a specific offence for sexual intercourse on a false promise to marry.
The legal test
- The key distinction is between a promise that was false from the start, made without any intention of keeping it, and a genuine promise later broken; only the first is deceit.
- The offence focuses on the accused's intention at the time the promise was made, which has to be inferred from his conduct before and after the act.
- The promise must also have been the reason the woman agreed; consent given for other reasons, such as mutual affection, is not vitiated merely because marriage did not follow.
BNS s.69 and application
- Section 69: whoever, by deceitful means or by making a promise to marry a woman without any intention of fulfilling it, has sexual intercourse with her, such intercourse not amounting to the offence of rape, is punished with imprisonment of either description up to ten years and fine.
- Explanation: deceitful means include inducement for, or false promise of, employment or promotion, or marrying by suppressing identity.
- Facts pointing to a false promise: Y was reluctant and agreed only after repeated assurances; X withdrew within fifteen days; the reasons he gave (career plans, need to marry an NRI to settle abroad) are long-term plans that probably existed when the promise was made.
- Facts for the defence: there is no direct proof yet of what X intended on the day of the promise; a change of mind after the act is not by itself an offence.
- Conclusion on facts: the prosecution has a strong case under s.69 if it proves X's plans pre-dated the promise; s.69 now covers the field where the intercourse does not amount to rape under s.63.
Recent changes in sexual offences law
- Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013 (after the Justice J.S. Verma Committee report): widened the definition of rape beyond vaginal penetration, made the victim's character irrelevant, and added offences such as acid attack, sexual harassment, disrobing, voyeurism and stalking.
- BNS 2023 (in force 1 July 2024): sexual offences are placed in Chapter V, 'Of offences against woman and child'; rape is defined in s.63 and punished under s.64(1) with rigorous imprisonment of not less than ten years extending to life, and fine.
- Section 69 is a new offence of sexual intercourse by deceitful means or false promise to marry.
- Gang rape: the age up to which a victim is treated as a minor is raised from 16 to 18; gang rape of a woman under eighteen is punishable with imprisonment for the remainder of natural life and fine, or death (s.70(2)).
- Exception 2 to s.63 retains the marital exception, but the wife must not be under eighteen; disclosure of the identity of victims is punishable with up to two years and fine (s.72(1)); IPC s.377 is not retained.
- Under the BNSS, a victim's statement may also be recorded through audio-video electronic means (s.176), and the medical report of a rape victim must be forwarded to the investigating officer within seven days (s.184).
Conclusion
On these facts X is likely liable under BNS s.69 if his intention not to marry existed at the time of the promise; the BNS fills a gap by treating deceitful sexual relations as a distinct offence, while courts must guard against criminalising failed consensual relationships.
Examples and data to cite
- BNS 2023 s.69: deceitful means or false promise to marry
- BNS s.28: consent given under fear of injury or misconception of fact
- BNS s.63 Exception 2: wife not under eighteen
- BNS s.70(2): gang rape of a woman under eighteen
- Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013 (after the Justice J.S. Verma Committee report of 23 January 2013)
Facts to remember
- BNS s.69: imprisonment up to ten years and fine.
- BNS s.28: consent known to be given under fear or misconception.
- BNS s.63 defines rape; s.64(1) punishment, rigorous imprisonment of not less than ten years extending to life, and fine.
- BNS in force from 1 July 2024.