'X', a public servant, asks 'Y', a person to give him an amount of Rupees ten thousand in order to process 'Y's routine application for a cooking gas connection on time. What offence, if any, has 'X' committed ? Explain in the light of the relevant statutory provisions. Refer to leading cases.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
X is guilty under s.7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 as amended in 2018: by asking for Rs 10,000 he attempted to obtain an undue advantage, and Explanation 1 to s.7 makes this an offence even though the duty he was to perform (processing a routine application on time) is not itself improper; punishment is three to seven years' imprisonment and fine.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Apply s.7 as amended, its Explanation and illustration, to the facts; identify that no payment or improper performance is needed; mention the related provisions on bribe-giving, prior approval for inquiry and the statutory presumption.
Answer outline
Introduction
Bribery of public servants is governed by the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; the Prevention of Corruption (Amendment) Act, 2018, in force from 26 July 2018, replaced 'gratification other than legal remuneration' with 'undue advantage'.
Ingredients of s.7
- X is a public servant within the meaning of the Act.
- Section 7(a): a public servant who obtains or accepts or attempts to obtain from any person an undue advantage, with the intention to perform or cause performance of public duty improperly or dishonestly, or to forbear, commits the offence.
- Explanation 1: obtaining, accepting or attempting to obtain an undue advantage shall itself constitute an offence even if the performance of a public duty by the public servant is not or has not been improper.
- The statutory illustration is almost the present facts: a public servant who asks a person to give him five thousand rupees to process his routine ration card application on time is guilty under s.7.
- Explanation 2: 'obtains', 'accepts' and 'attempts to obtain' cover cases where the benefit is for another person or is received through a third party.
- Punishment: imprisonment of not less than three years, extendable to seven years, and fine.
Application
- The demand of Rs 10,000 is an attempt to obtain an undue advantage; the offence is complete on the demand, and payment is not necessary.
- That the gas connection was a routine, lawful service is irrelevant because of Explanation 1.
- If Y pays, giving an undue advantage is itself an offence under s.8, but the proviso protects a person compelled to give it who reports the matter to the law enforcement authority or investigating agency within seven days of giving it.
- Under s.17A a police officer needs prior approval to inquire into a public servant's decisions in discharge of official functions, but no approval is needed where a person is arrested on the spot on the charge of accepting or attempting to accept an undue advantage; prosecution of a serving public servant also needs prior sanction.
Proof and presumption
- Section 20: where it is proved that a public servant accepted or obtained an undue advantage, the court presumes, unless the contrary is proved, that he did so as a motive or reward for performing a public duty improperly or dishonestly.
- Where only a demand is made, as here, the prosecution must prove the demand itself, for example through Y's complaint, recorded conversations or a trap.
- The amended Act also makes bribe-giving by commercial organisations an offence (s.9), showing the shift to targeting both sides of a corrupt transaction.
Conclusion
X has committed the offence of attempting to obtain an undue advantage under s.7 of the PC Act; the 2018 amendment removes any argument that 'speed money' for a lawful act is not bribery.
Examples and data to cite
- Prevention of Corruption (Amendment) Act, 2018 (in force 26 July 2018)
- Illustration to Explanation 1, s.7: Rs 5,000 to process a routine ration card application on time
- Section 8 proviso: compelled giver who reports within seven days
- Section 17A proviso: arrest on the spot
Facts to remember
- PC Act s.7: three to seven years and fine.
- Bribe giving is a distinct offence under s.8 after 2018.
- Section 17A requires prior approval for a police inquiry, except where a person is arrested on the spot.
- Section 20 raises a presumption once taking of an undue advantage is proved.