Answer the following questions in about 150 words each. Support your answer with relevant legal provisions and judicial pronouncements.
(c) Write a note on ‘non-partners’ who can share the profits in a partnership.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write a note
The core of a good answer
Section 6 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 makes the real relation between the parties, not mere receipt of a share of profits, the test of partnership; its Explanation 2 names lenders, servants and agents, widows or children of deceased partners and sellers of goodwill as persons who may share profits without becoming partners, and minors admitted to the benefits of partnership and transferees of a partner's interest also share profits without being partners.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A short note listing the categories of profit-sharers who are not partners, anchored in section 6 and the rule in Cox v Hickman that profit-sharing is only evidence of partnership.
Answer outline
Introduction
Section 4 defines partnership as the relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all; section 6 adds that sharing of profits is not conclusive.
The rule
- Section 6: in determining whether a group of persons is a firm, regard is had to the real relation between the parties as shown by all relevant facts taken together.
- Explanation 1: sharing of profits or of gross returns arising from property by persons holding a joint or common interest in that property does not of itself make them partners.
- Explanation 2: receipt of a share of profits, or of a payment contingent on or varying with profits, does not of itself make the receiver a partner.
Non-partners named in Explanation 2
- A lender of money to persons engaged or about to engage in business.
- A servant or agent who receives a share of profits as remuneration.
- The widow or child of a deceased partner receiving an annuity out of profits.
- A previous owner or part-owner of the business receiving a share of profits as consideration for the sale of its goodwill.
Other profit-sharers outside the firm
- Minor admitted to the benefits of partnership under section 30: with the consent of all partners, takes an agreed share of property and profits; his share is liable for acts of the firm but he is not personally liable, and he cannot be a partner while a minor.
- Transferee of a partner's interest (section 29): cannot interfere in the business, demand accounts or inspect the books while the firm continues, but is entitled to receive the transferring partner's share of profits.
Conclusion
Because the business must be carried on by all or any of them acting for all (section 4), a person who shares profits but on whose behalf the business is not carried on is not a partner.
Examples and data to cite
- Cox v Hickman (1860): House of Lords held that sharing profits is not a conclusive test; persons sharing profits are liable as partners only if the business is carried on by them personally or through others as their real or ostensible agents.
- Mollwo, March and Co v Court of Wards (1872): Privy Council held that although a right to share profits is a strong test of partnership, whether the relation exists depends on the real intention and contract of the parties.
- K.D. Kamath and Co v CIT (1971): Supreme Court held that the two essential conditions are an agreement to share profits (and losses) and the business being carried on by all or any of them acting for all.
Facts to remember
- The Indian Partnership Act, 1932 came into force on 1 October 1932 (section 69 on 1 October 1933).
- Section 6, like the rule in Cox v Hickman, looks to the real relation of the parties rather than to profit-sharing alone.
- A minor cannot be a partner but may be admitted to the benefits of partnership with the consent of all partners (section 30).
- Section 29 gives the transferee of a partner's interest the right to receive that partner's share of profits only.