“Sharing of profits is only prima facie evidence of the existence of a partnership. The conclusive test is that of ‘mutual-agency’.” In view of the above statement, discuss the essential features of a partnership.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Section 4 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 has four elements: an agreement, a business, sharing of profits, and the business carried on by all or any of them acting for all; since Cox v Hickman (1860), and under section 6, profit-sharing is not conclusive, and the decisive question is whether the business is carried on by all or any of them acting for all, each partner being the agent of the firm (section 18).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The statement is the Cox v Hickman rule codified in section 6. The answer must explain each element of section 4, show why profit-sharing is not decisive, and why mutual agency is treated as the true test, with Indian cases.
Answer outline
Introduction
Partnership is a relation arising from contract, not status (section 5); its definition in section 4 is built around profit-sharing and acting for all.
Agreement
- Partnership arises from contract and not from status (section 5); members of a Hindu undivided family carrying on a family business are not partners merely by that status.
Business
- Section 2(b): business includes every trade, occupation and profession.
- A person may become a partner with another in particular adventures or undertakings (section 8).
Sharing of profits
- Agreement to share profits is essential (section 4); the Supreme Court in K.D. Kamath and Co v CIT speaks of an agreement to share the profits as well as the losses of the business.
- Waugh v Carver (1793) approved the doctrine that every man who has a share of the profits of a trade ought also to bear his share of the loss; since Cox v Hickman (1860) profit-sharing has not been a conclusive test.
- Section 6 Explanation 2: lenders, servants or agents, widows or children of deceased partners and sellers of goodwill may share profits without being partners.
Mutual agency: the conclusive test
- Business must be carried on by all or any of them acting for all; each partner is agent of the firm (section 18) with implied authority (section 19).
- This makes all partners jointly and severally liable for acts of the firm (section 25) and for wrongful acts of a partner in the ordinary course of business (section 26).
- Under Cox v Hickman, persons who share profits are liable as partners only if the business is carried on by them personally or through others as their real or ostensible agents.
Conclusion
Profit-sharing shows the motive for association, but mutual agency shows its legal character; courts therefore look at the real relation of the parties as a whole, as section 6 directs.
Examples and data to cite
- Cox v Hickman (1860): House of Lords held that profit-sharing is not a conclusive test; liability as partner depends on the business being carried on by the persons or by agents on their behalf.
- Mollwo, March and Co v Court of Wards (1872): Privy Council held that whether a partnership exists depends on the real intention and contract of the parties.
- K.D. Kamath and Co v CIT (1971): Supreme Court identified an agreement to share profits and losses and the business being carried on by all or any of them acting for all as the essential conditions, and held that vesting exclusive control in one partner by agreement is not destructive of partnership.
Facts to remember
- Section 4: partnership is the relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all.
- Section 5: partnership is not created by status.
- Section 6: real relation of the parties, shown by all relevant facts taken together, decides whether a firm exists.
- Section 18: subject to the Act, a partner is the agent of the firm for the purpose of the business of the firm.
- Section 25: every partner is liable jointly with all other partners and also severally for all acts of the firm done while he is a partner.