Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(a) Do you think that the traditional roles of managers are still relevant in today’s digital and remote work environment ? Critically comment with examples.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically comment
The core of a good answer
The traditional managerial functions and roles remain relevant, but their form has changed: planning, coordinating and controlling are now done through digital tools and outcomes, while the interpersonal roles of leading, connecting and motivating have become harder and more important in remote teams.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks whether classical descriptions of the manager's job (Fayol's functions, Mintzberg's roles) still hold when work is digital and distributed. 'Critically comment' needs a balanced verdict: show what survives, what has been automated or redistributed, and what has become more demanding, with examples.
Answer outline
Introduction
Fayol (1916) described management as planning, organising, commanding, coordinating and controlling; Henry Mintzberg's The Nature of Managerial Work (1973) looked at the manager's job in practice.
What remains relevant
- Planning and goal setting matter more when teams are dispersed: clear objectives and outcome measures (for example OKRs) replace physical supervision.
- Interpersonal work (leading people and building relationships) carries the burden of trust, belonging and motivation that the office used to provide informally.
- Decision-making work (initiating change, handling disturbances, allocating resources, negotiating) is unchanged in substance: someone must still allocate budgets and resolve conflicts.
What has changed
- Control shifts from watching inputs (hours, presence) to measuring outputs; monitoring software that tracks keystrokes raises trust and privacy problems.
- Information work (monitoring, passing on information, speaking for the team) is partly automated by dashboards and collaboration platforms, but the manager must now curate information and avoid overload.
- Coordination becomes asynchronous across time zones and needs written documentation and explicit norms.
Critical view
- Self-managing and agile teams reduce the need for command, so the manager acts more as coach and facilitator.
- Yet remote work increases isolation, weak onboarding and proximity bias, which only active managerial attention can correct.
Conclusion
The roles are not obsolete; they are being re-performed through different means, with a shift from command and control to enabling, coaching and outcome-based coordination.
Examples and data to cite
- All-remote firms such as GitLab rely on a public, handbook-first approach and asynchronous communication to perform the coordinating role.
Facts to remember
- Fayol's five functions: planning, organising, commanding, coordinating, controlling (Administration industrielle et générale, 1916).