Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(e) “Ethical management is essential for long-term organisational success.” Critically evaluate the statement with examples.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically evaluate
The core of a good answer
The statement largely holds: ethical conduct builds trust with customers, employees, investors and regulators, which sustains performance, while unethical shortcuts can collapse even large firms; but ethics is necessary rather than sufficient, and in the short run unethical firms sometimes prosper.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Critically evaluate' requires weighing the claim: give arguments and evidence for it, note its limits (time horizon, enforcement gaps, ethics alone does not guarantee success), and reach a reasoned judgment with corporate examples.
Answer outline
Introduction
Ethical management means running the business on values of honesty, fairness and responsibility towards all stakeholders, embedded in governance, culture and decisions.
Arguments in support
- Trust and reputation are intangible assets that take decades to build and can be lost overnight.
- Lower legal, regulatory and litigation risk; better access to capital as investors use ESG criteria.
- Employee commitment and retention rise when people believe in the organisation's integrity.
- Stakeholder theory: long-term value depends on relationships with all stakeholders, not only shareholders.
Critical points
- Some unethical firms grow fast before being caught; detection and enforcement are uneven.
- Ethics can be treated as window dressing (greenwashing, token codes of conduct).
- Ethical firms can still fail through poor strategy; ethics is necessary, not sufficient.
Making ethics work
- Tone at the top, codes of conduct, vigil mechanisms and whistleblower protection, ethics training, and incentives that do not reward misconduct.
Conclusion
Over the long run, ethical management is a precondition for sustained success, because the costs of unethical conduct eventually surface; the challenge is to build ethics into systems and incentives rather than slogans.
Examples and data to cite
- Satyam Computer Services: chairman Ramalinga Raju's confession on 7 January 2009 of large-scale falsification of accounts led to the company's collapse; Tech Mahindra bought a 31 per cent stake through a public auction on 13 April 2009.
- Volkswagen's emissions scandal (September 2015): defeat device software that cheated diesel emissions tests led to large fines, recalls and reputational damage.
- Wells Fargo (2016): staff under aggressive sales targets opened unauthorised customer accounts; the bank was fined 185 million US dollars.
- Johnson and Johnson's 1982 nationwide recall of Tylenol after tampering deaths is often cited as an ethics-led decision that restored trust.
Facts to remember
- Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 requires qualifying companies to spend at least 2 per cent of their average net profits of the preceding three years on CSR.
- Freeman's stakeholder theory (1984) argues that firms must create value for all stakeholders.