What is the relationship between Organisational Culture and the successful implementation of a Performance Management System ? Discuss with suitable examples.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Organisational culture and a performance management system shape each other: a PMS succeeds only when its design (goals, feedback, ratings, rewards) fits the shared values and assumptions of the organisation, and a well-designed PMS can in turn reinforce or deliberately change that culture.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the two-way relationship between culture and PMS, the cultural conditions for success and the reasons for failure, with company examples. 'Discuss' needs analysis, not just definitions.
Answer outline
Introduction
Organisational culture is the pattern of shared values and basic assumptions that guide behaviour (Schein: artifacts and behaviours, espoused values, underlying assumptions); a PMS is the continuous process of setting goals, monitoring, appraising, developing and rewarding performance.
How culture shapes PMS success
- Trust and openness: candid feedback works only where employees trust managers and fear no reprisal.
- Collectivist or team cultures resist highly individual, forced-ranking systems; individualistic, market cultures accept them more readily.
- High power distance makes upward feedback and 360-degree appraisal difficult.
- Learning cultures use PMS for development; blame cultures turn it into a ritual of rating and defence.
How PMS shapes culture
- What is measured and rewarded signals what is valued: sales-only targets can produce aggressive or unethical behaviour, while balanced goals reinforce collaboration and customer focus.
- A shift to continuous feedback can move a culture from control to coaching.
Reasons for failure when the two clash
- Imported best-practice systems that ignore local culture; manager-employee mistrust; rating inflation; perceived unfairness.
- Forced distribution that breeds internal competition in a culture that needs teamwork.
Achieving fit
- Diagnose the existing culture before designing the system.
- Involve employees in design; train managers in coaching; ensure transparency and appeals; align rewards with stated values; pilot and review.
Conclusion
Culture is the soil in which a PMS grows; the system works when it fits the culture or when leaders change both together on purpose.
Examples and data to cite
- Microsoft dropped stack ranking in 2013 (announced 12 November 2013) because it was seen as fostering internal competition rather than collaboration.
- Adobe abandoned ranking-based annual reviews in 2012.
- Accenture was reported in 2015 to be getting rid of annual reviews and rankings.
- Wells Fargo (2016): aggressive sales targets in its performance system contributed to staff opening unauthorised accounts.
Facts to remember
- Edgar Schein, Organizational Culture and Leadership: three levels of culture (artifacts and behaviours, espoused values, basic underlying assumptions).
- GE under Jack Welch used a vitality curve (20 per cent top, 70 per cent middle, 10 per cent bottom).
- Balanced scorecard (Kaplan and Norton, 1992) links individual goals to strategy.