Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Analyse the impact of adopting historical cost and fair value methods on the reliability and relevance of financial information, especially during periods of market fluctuations and economic uncertainty.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Analyse
The core of a good answer
Historical cost gives reliable, verifiable but often stale figures, while fair value gives relevant, current figures whose reliability falls as markets become illiquid and estimates move to Level 3; in volatile periods the trade-off sharpens, so a mixed measurement model with strong disclosure serves users best.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks you to weigh two measurement bases against two qualities of financial information, relevance and reliability, and to show how the balance shifts when markets swing or freeze. 'Analyse' needs causes and effects, not just definitions, and a balanced conclusion.
Answer outline
Introduction
Historical cost is the value of the costs incurred in acquiring or creating an asset; fair value, under IFRS 13, is the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date.
Historical cost: effect on reliability and relevance
- Reliability is high: values rest on actual transactions and invoices, are objective, verifiable and hard to manipulate.
- Relevance is low when prices change: assets bought years ago are understated, depreciation is too small, and profit is overstated in inflation (capital is not maintained in real terms).
- Gains on appreciated assets stay hidden until sale, which allows 'cherry picking' of disposals to manage earnings.
- Conservative by design: recorded amounts are not updated for increases in value, so assets are not written up in a rising market.
Fair value: effect on reliability and relevance
- Relevance is high: balance sheets show current economic worth, useful for investors, lenders and regulators assessing solvency and risk.
- Reliability depends on the input level: Level 1 (quoted prices in active markets) is reliable; Level 2 (observable inputs for similar items) less so; Level 3 (unobservable, model-based inputs) involves judgement and possible bias.
- Unrealised gains and losses flow into profit or other comprehensive income, making earnings volatile.
During market fluctuations and economic uncertainty
- In a falling, illiquid market fair value may reflect distressed or forced prices; marking down assets can trigger margin calls, forced sales and further price falls (pro-cyclicality).
- In rising markets, Adair Turner (as reported on the mark-to-market accounting page) argued that mark-to-market produces a self-reinforcing cycle that feeds into banks' profit estimates.
- Historical cost does not record gains until they are realised and does not show changes in value, so in a crisis the accounts can lag behind economic reality, which is itself a relevance failure.
- Standard setters responded by clarifying fair value in inactive markets rather than abandoning it.
Balancing the two
- Mixed measurement model: fair value where active market prices exist (for example, traded financial instruments) and cost for operating assets held for use.
- Disclosure of the fair value hierarchy, valuation techniques and sensitivity of Level 3 inputs restores some reliability.
Conclusion
Neither basis is superior in all conditions: historical cost trades relevance for reliability and fair value does the reverse, and the gap widens in volatile markets; transparent disclosure and a principled mixed model are the practical answer.
Examples and data to cite
- IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement was adopted by the IASB on 12 May 2011 and took effect on 1 January 2013.
- 2008 global financial crisis: banks recognised large losses by marking mortgage-backed securities to market; on 30 September 2008 the SEC and FASB jointly clarified that forced liquidations do not indicate fair value.
- US Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, 3 October 2008, section 133 required an SEC study; the SEC report of 30 December 2008 recommended against suspending fair value accounting.
- April 2009: FASB eased guidance for fair value when markets are inactive.
- Enron was the first non-financial company to use mark-to-market accounting for its complex long-term contracts (the SEC approved the method for its natural gas futures trading on 30 January 1992), which shows the manipulation risk of model-based values.
Facts to remember
- Fair value: price to sell an asset or transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date (IFRS 13).
- Fair value hierarchy: Level 1 quoted prices for identical items in active markets; Level 2 other observable inputs; Level 3 unobservable inputs.
- Historical cost amounts are not updated for changes in the items' values, and historical cost accounts do not record gains until they are realised.
- In April 2009 FASB updated FAS 157 to ease the mark-to-market rules when the market is unsteady or inactive.