A company operates under the following conditions :
Selling Price = ₹60
Variable Cost = ₹50
Fixed Cost = ₹1,00,000
Capacity = 20,000 units
Expected Sales = 8,000 units
Shut-down Cost = ₹20,000
Assess whether the company should continue its operations or shut down, based on a careful evaluation of its financial and operational position. Suggest suitable justification for your decision.
15 marks · directive: Assess
The core of a good answer
At 8,000 units the contribution of ₹80,000 leaves a loss of ₹20,000, exactly equal to the ₹20,000 loss from shutting down; 8,000 units is the shut-down point, so the company is financially indifferent and should continue, since every unit sold above 8,000 makes operating better and non-financial factors favour staying open.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A marginal costing (shut-down point) decision: compare the loss from operating with the unavoidable cost of closing, using contribution analysis, break-even and shut-down point, then justify with operational and qualitative factors.
Answer outline
Introduction
Data: selling price ₹60, variable cost ₹50 per unit, fixed cost ₹1,00,000, capacity 20,000 units, expected sales 8,000 units (40 per cent of capacity), shut-down cost ₹20,000 (fixed costs that will be incurred even if operations are suspended; the rest of the fixed cost is avoidable on closure).
Step 1: Contribution
- Contribution per unit = 60 − 50 = ₹10
- P/V ratio = 10/60 = 16.67%
- Total contribution at 8,000 units = 8,000 × 10 = ₹80,000
Step 2: Result if operations continue
- Profit = 80,000 − 1,00,000 = −₹20,000 (loss of ₹20,000)
Step 3: Result if the plant is shut down
- Revenue and variable costs become nil; only the shut-down cost of ₹20,000 is incurred
- Loss on shut-down = ₹20,000
Step 4: Break-even and shut-down points
- Break-even point = 1,00,000/10 = 10,000 units (₹6,00,000 sales); expected sales are 2,000 units below it
- Shut-down point = (fixed cost − shut-down cost)/contribution per unit = (1,00,000 − 20,000)/10 = 8,000 units
- Expected sales equal the shut-down point, so the two alternatives give the same loss
Step 5: Operational and qualitative assessment
- Price (₹60) exceeds average variable cost (₹50), so the short-run economic rule also favours operating
- Continuing keeps trained workers, customers, dealers and market share; avoids reopening costs
- Any sale above 8,000 units reduces the loss (each extra unit adds ₹10); at full capacity profit would be 20,000 × 10 − 1,00,000 = ₹1,00,000
- Shut down only if demand is expected to stay below 8,000 units for a long period, or the resources have better alternative uses
- Action plan: raise volume (40 per cent capacity is low), cut variable cost, review fixed costs, consider export or job-work orders at any price above ₹50
Conclusion
Financially the company is indifferent at 8,000 units (loss ₹20,000 either way); because sales above the shut-down point make operating better and closure carries hidden costs, the company should continue and work to raise volume. Check: 8,000 × 10 = 80,000 = 1,00,000 − 20,000.
Examples and data to cite
- All figures recomputed in Python: contribution ₹80,000, operating loss ₹20,000, BEP 10,000 units, shut-down point 8,000 units.
- If the shut-down cost were read as additional to the full fixed cost (all fixed costs continuing), closure would cost ₹1,20,000 against an operating loss of ₹20,000, which makes continuing even more clearly right.
Facts to remember
- Contribution = sales − variable cost; P/V ratio = contribution/sales.
- Break-even is where total contribution equals fixed cost, so break-even units = fixed cost / contribution per unit.
- Shut-down point (units) = avoidable fixed cost / contribution per unit = (total fixed cost − shut-down cost) / contribution per unit, taking the shut-down cost as the fixed cost incurred even on closure (non-sunk costs are compared with price, sunk costs ignored).
- Short-run shutdown rule: operate if price ≥ average variable cost (revenue covers variable cost).
- Margin of safety = expected sales − break-even sales (here 8,000 − 10,000 = −2,000 units).