A manufacturing enterprise is evaluating a long-term investment proposal aimed at modernizing its production facilities. The project entails a substantial capital outlay on fixed assets, along with an additional investment in working capital to sustain operational activities throughout the project period. The management intends to assess the proposal using the Net Present Value (NPV) method, taking into account all relevant cash flows, including terminal recoveries.
The project details are as follows :
Initial investment in fixed assets : ₹8,00,000
Additional working capital requirement : ₹1,00,000
(fully recoverable at the end of the project)
Project life : 4 years
Scrap value of assets at the end of Year 4 : ₹50,000
Annual cash inflows : ₹3,00,000
Cost of Capital : 10%
Answer the following :
(i) Calculate the Net Present Value (NPV) of the project by appropriately considering the initial investment, working capital commitment, annual cash inflows and terminal cash recoveries. [10 marks]
(ii) Based on the computed NPV, evaluate the financial feasibility of the project and justify your recommendation. [4 marks]
(iii) Discuss the significance of incorporating working capital requirements and terminal cash inflows in capital budgeting decisions and explain how their omission may affect project appraisal outcomes. [6 marks]
20 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
NPV = −₹9,00,000 + ₹3,00,000 × 3.1699 + ₹1,50,000 × 0.6830 ≈ +₹1,53,412 (₹1,53,450 with three-decimal tables), so the project is financially feasible and should be accepted; omitting the working capital outlay or the terminal recoveries would misstate NPV, in this case from about ₹51,000 to ₹1,85,000.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A standard NPV problem: build the cash flow profile (outflow at year 0 including working capital, equal annual inflows, terminal inflows of scrap and working capital in year 4), discount at 10 per cent, then interpret and discuss the role of working capital and terminal flows.
Answer outline
Introduction
Year 0 outflow = fixed assets ₹8,00,000 + working capital ₹1,00,000 = ₹9,00,000. Years 1 to 4 inflow ₹3,00,000 each (taken as net cash inflows; no tax data are given). Year 4 terminal inflow = scrap ₹50,000 + working capital release ₹1,00,000 = ₹1,50,000. Discount rate 10 per cent.
Step 1: Discount factors at 10%
- Year 1: 1/1.1 = 0.9091
- Year 2: 1/1.1² = 0.8264
- Year 3: 1/1.1³ = 0.7513
- Year 4: 1/1.1⁴ = 0.6830
- Annuity factor (4 years) = 3.1699
Step 2: Present value of annual inflows
- PV = 3,00,000 × 3.1699 = ₹9,50,960
Step 3: Present value of terminal recoveries
- Scrap: 50,000 × 0.6830 = ₹34,151
- Working capital release: 1,00,000 × 0.6830 = ₹68,301
- Total terminal PV = 1,50,000 × 0.6830 = ₹1,02,452
Step 4: NPV (part i)
- Total PV of inflows = 9,50,960 + 1,02,452 = ₹10,53,412
- Less initial outlay (8,00,000 + 1,00,000) = ₹9,00,000
- NPV = 10,53,412 − 9,00,000 = ₹1,53,412 (about ₹1,53,450 using factors 3.170 and 0.683)
Step 5: Feasibility (part ii)
- NPV > 0, so the project earns more than the 10% cost of capital and adds about ₹1.53 lakh to firm value: accept.
- Profitability index = 10,53,412/9,00,000 = 1.17
- IRR ≈ 17.2% (greater than 10%)
- Simple payback = 3 years (cumulative inflows reach ₹9,00,000 at end of year 3)
- Caveats: inflows assumed certain and after tax; test sensitivity to lower inflows or higher discount rate.
Step 6: Significance of working capital and terminal flows (part iii)
- Working capital is a real cash commitment at the start: ignoring it understates the outlay; here NPV would wrongly rise to ₹1,85,110 if both the outlay and its recovery were left out, because money tied up for 4 years has a time cost of ₹1,00,000 − ₹68,301 = ₹31,699.
- Terminal recoveries (scrap and release of working capital) are genuine inflows: ignoring them while counting the outlay would cut NPV to ₹50,960, possibly rejecting good projects.
- Ignoring only the working capital recovery gives NPV ₹85,110.
- Omissions distort ranking of mutually exclusive projects, especially those with different working capital intensity or salvage values, and bias IRR and payback.
- Relevant cash flow principle: include all incremental cash flows, including working capital changes and terminal values, and exclude sunk costs.
Conclusion
NPV ≈ ₹1,53,412 at 10%, profitability index 1.17 and IRR about 17.2%: the modernisation is financially feasible and should be accepted. Check: 3,00,000 × 3.16987 + 1,50,000 × 0.68301 − 9,00,000 = 1,53,412.
Examples and data to cite
- All discount factors, NPV, IRR and the omission scenarios were recomputed in Python with exact fractions.
Facts to remember
- NPV is the sum of all discounted future cash flows less the initial outlay; projects with a positive NPV should be accepted.
- Present value annuity factor = [1 − (1 + k)⁻ⁿ]/k = 3.1699 for k = 10%, n = 4 (a finite geometric series).
- IRR is the discount rate that gives an NPV of zero.
- Capital budgeting uses the incremental cash flows from each project; here the question states that working capital is fully recoverable at the end of the project and gives a scrap value at the end of Year 4.