Distinguish between Foreign Direct Investment and Foreign Portfolio Investment. Explain the impact of each of these on the economy.
15 marks · directive: Distinguish / Explain
The core of a good answer
FDI is a lasting investment with management control (by the international convention, 10 per cent or more of a company's shares), bringing capital, technology and jobs; FPI is a passive, liquid investment in securities below that threshold that deepens capital markets but can reverse quickly and add volatility.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
7 marks for a point by point distinction and 8 marks for the economic impact of each, both positive and negative. A comparison table style answer with Indian rules and episodes works best.
Answer outline
Introduction
Foreign investment comes either as direct investment in productive enterprises or as portfolio investment in financial assets; the two differ in intent, control, duration and stability.
Distinctions
- Control: FDI seeks lasting interest and a say in management; FPI is passive.
- Threshold: equity holdings of less than 10 per cent of a company's shares are classified as portfolio investment (IMF BPM6), and India's FDI framework uses the same 10 per cent line.
- Horizon and liquidity: FDI long term and illiquid; FPI short term and easily sold.
- Form: FDI in plant, equity stakes, greenfield or brownfield; FPI in shares, bonds, mutual fund units.
- Regulation: FDI under the policy of the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), through the automatic route (no prior approval of Government or RBI) or the government route (prior approval); FPI is regulated by SEBI.
- Stability: FDI is relatively stable; FPI liquidity depends on market volatility and flows can reverse quickly.
Impact of FDI
- Capital formation, technology and managerial know how transfer.
- Employment, exports and integration with global value chains.
- Competition and productivity spillovers.
- Concerns: crowding out of domestic firms, profit repatriation, strategic sectors (hence the April 2020 order bringing FDI from countries sharing a land border with India under government scrutiny).
Impact of FPI
- Deepens stock and bond markets, improves liquidity and price discovery, lowers cost of capital.
- Finances current account deficit.
- Risks: sudden stops and outflows, rupee volatility, transmission of global shocks.
Conclusion
India's policy rightly prefers stable FDI while welcoming FPI with macroprudential safeguards; strong reserves and a balanced mix limit the risk of reversals.
Examples and data to cite
- In April 2020 India subjected FDI from countries sharing a land border with it to scrutiny by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry; the change was built into the Consolidated FDI Policy of 28 October 2020.
Facts to remember
- IMF BPM6 classifies equity holdings below 10 per cent of a company's shares as portfolio investment; direct investment begins at 10 per cent.
- FPI is a grouping of assets such as stocks (below the 10 per cent line), bonds and cash equivalents.
- FDI routes: automatic (no prior approval by Government or RBI) and government (prior approval, applications via the Foreign Investment Facilitation Portal).