If the sum of the lengths of the hypotenuse and another side of a right-angled triangle be given, then find the angle between these sides so that the area of the triangle is maximum.
15 marks · directive: Find
The core of a good answer
With side b, hypotenuse h and b + h = k fixed, the area is maximum when b = k/3 and h = 2k/3, i.e. when cos θ = b/h = 1/2, so the angle between the hypotenuse and that side is θ = π/3 (60°); the maximum area is √3k²/18.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
An application of maxima and minima. Express the area as a function of one variable using the fixed sum, find the stationary point, confirm it is a maximum with the second derivative (or sign change), and convert the result into the angle between the hypotenuse and the given side.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let the given side be b, the hypotenuse h, with b + h = k (constant), and the third side √(h² − b²). The angle θ between the hypotenuse and side b satisfies cos θ = b/h. Area Δ = (1/2) b √(h² − b²).
Step 1: Area in one variable
- h = k − b, so h² − b² = (k − b)² − b² = k² − 2kb
- Δ = (1/2) b √(k² − 2kb), with 0 < b < k/2
- Maximise S = Δ² · 4 = b²(k² − 2kb) = k²b² − 2kb³ (same maximiser, since Δ > 0)
Step 2: Stationary point
- dS/db = 2k²b − 6kb² = 2kb(k − 3b)
- dS/db = 0 with b > 0 gives b = k/3
Step 3: Nature of the stationary point
- d²S/db² = 2k² − 12kb; at b = k/3 this is 2k² − 4k² = −2k² < 0, so S (and Δ) is maximum.
- Also dS/db > 0 for b < k/3 and < 0 for b > k/3.
Step 4: The angle
- b = k/3, h = k − k/3 = 2k/3
- cos θ = b/h = (k/3)/(2k/3) = 1/2, so θ = π/3
- Maximum area = (1/2)(k/3)√(4k²/9 − k²/9) = (1/2)(k/3)(√3 k/3) = √3k²/18
Alternative in θ
- b = k cos θ/(1 + cos θ), h = k/(1 + cos θ), Δ = (1/2) b h sin θ = k² sin θ cos θ/[2(1 + cos θ)²]
- dΔ/dθ = k²(cos θ + cos 2θ)/[2(1 + cos θ)³]; zero when 2cos²θ + cos θ − 1 = 0, i.e. (2cos θ − 1)(cos θ + 1) = 0, so cos θ = 1/2.
Conclusion
The area is greatest when the angle between the hypotenuse and the given side is π/3 (60°), the side being one third and the hypotenuse two thirds of the given sum. This was checked symbolically with sympy in both the side and the angle formulation.
Examples and data to cite
- At the optimum the triangle is the 30°-60°-90° triangle with sides in the ratio 1 : √3 : 2.
- For k = 6 cm: side 2 cm, hypotenuse 4 cm, third side 2√3 cm, area 2√3 cm² = √3 · 36/18.
Facts to remember
- For a differentiable function, a local maximum at an interior point needs f'(c) = 0 and f''(c) < 0 is sufficient.
- Maximising Δ² instead of Δ is valid when Δ > 0, since squaring is increasing on positive numbers.
- In a right-angled triangle, cosine of an acute angle = adjacent side/hypotenuse.
- Area of a triangle = (1/2) × product of two sides × sine of the included angle.