Trace the curve y²(a + x) = x²(3a − x).
15 marks · directive: Trace
The core of a good answer
For a > 0 the curve is symmetric about the x-axis, exists only for −a < x ≤ 3a, has a node at the origin with tangents y = ±√3x, meets the x-axis again at (3a, 0) with a vertical tangent, has a loop on 0 ≤ x ≤ 3a with highest points at x = √3a, y = ±a√(6√3 − 9) ≈ ±1.18a, and two infinite branches in −a < x < 0 approaching the vertical asymptote x = −a.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Curve tracing follows a fixed checklist: symmetry, origin and tangents there, intercepts, asymptotes, region where the curve exists, special points (turning points, tangents at intercepts) and then the sketch described in words. Each item must be justified from the equation.
Answer outline
Introduction
Assume a > 0. Write the curve as y² = x²(3a − x)/(a + x).
Step 1: Symmetry
- Only even powers of y occur, so the curve is symmetric about the x-axis.
- Replacing x by −x changes the equation, so there is no symmetry about the y-axis.
Step 2: Origin
- (0, 0) satisfies the equation, so the curve passes through the origin.
- Lowest degree terms: ay² − 3ax² = 0, i.e. y² = 3x², so tangents at the origin are y = √3x and y = −√3x.
- Two real distinct tangents: the origin is a node (the curve crosses itself).
Step 3: Intercepts
- y = 0 gives x²(3a − x) = 0: x = 0 or x = 3a, so (3a, 0).
- At (3a, 0), shifting X = x − 3a, the lowest degree terms give 4a y² = −9a² X, so the tangent there is X = 0, the vertical line x = 3a.
- x = 0 gives y = 0 only.
Step 4: Asymptotes
- Highest degree terms: xy² + x³ = x(x² + y²); the only real linear factor is x, so the only real asymptote is parallel to the y-axis.
- Coefficient of y² is (a + x); equating to zero gives the asymptote x = −a.
- No horizontal or oblique asymptotes.
Step 5: Region of existence
- y² ≥ 0 needs (3a − x)/(a + x) ≥ 0 (or x = 0), i.e. −a < x ≤ 3a.
- No part of the curve lies to the left of x = −a or to the right of x = 3a.
- As x → −a from the right, y² → +∞, so y → ±∞.
Step 6: Turning points and monotonicity
- d(y²)/dx = −2x(x² − 3a²)/(a + x)²
- On 0 < x < 3a, this is zero at x = √3a; y² increases on (0, √3a) and decreases on (√3a, 3a).
- At x = √3a: y² = 3a²(3 − √3)/(1 + √3) = (6√3 − 9)a², so y = ±a√(6√3 − 9) ≈ ±1.18a.
- On −a < x < 0, d(y²)/dx < 0, so y² decreases from +∞ to 0 as x goes from −a to 0.
Step 7: Shape
- A loop between x = 0 and x = 3a, through the origin (along y = ±√3x) and (3a, 0), widest at x = √3a.
- Through the node the branches continue into −a < x < 0, one going up and one going down, each approaching the line x = −a asymptotically.
Conclusion
The traced curve is a symmetric loop on 0 ≤ x ≤ 3a with a node at the origin (tangents at 60° to the x-axis) and a vertical tangent at (3a, 0), together with two branches in the strip −a < x < 0 that run off to ±∞ along the asymptote x = −a. Turning-point values were checked with sympy.
Examples and data to cite
- The maximum ordinate of the loop, a√(6√3 − 9), is about 1.18a; for a = 1 the loop's highest point is near (1.732, 1.180).
Facts to remember
- Curve tracing checklist: symmetry, origin, tangents at the origin, intercepts, asymptotes, region, special points.
- Tangents at the origin are given by equating the lowest degree terms to zero.
- Asymptotes parallel to the y-axis: equate to zero the coefficient of the highest power of y.
- A double point with two real distinct tangents is a node.
- Only even powers of y imply symmetry about the x-axis.