If y₁ and y₂ are two solutions of dy/dx + P(x)y = Q(x), and y₂ = y₁u, then show that u = 1 + a e^(−∫(Q/y₁) dx), where a is a non-zero constant.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
Substituting y₂ = y₁u into the equation and using y₁′ + Py₁ = Q gives y₁u′ = Q(1 − u), a separable equation whose solution is u = 1 + a e^(−∫(Q/y₁) dx); a ≠ 0 because y₂ is a solution different from y₁.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The part tests whether the candidate can exploit the fact that y₁ already satisfies the linear first order equation, so that the substitution y₂ = y₁u reduces the problem to a separable equation in u. 'Show' means every step must be written out, including why the constant is non-zero.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given: y₁ and y₂ both satisfy y′ + P(x)y = Q(x), and y₂ = y₁u with u a function of x. Assume Q ≠ 0 and y₁ ≠ 0 on the interval considered.
Step 1: Use the fact that y₁ is a solution
- y₁′ + P y₁ = Q, so y₁′ = Q − P y₁
Step 2: Substitute y₂ = y₁u
- y₂′ = y₁′u + y₁u′
- y₂′ + P y₂ = y₁′u + y₁u′ + P y₁u = u(y₁′ + P y₁) + y₁u′ = uQ + y₁u′
- Since y₂ is a solution: uQ + y₁u′ = Q
- Hence y₁u′ = Q(1 − u), that is du/dx = (Q/y₁)(1 − u)
Step 3: Separate the variables
- If u ≡ 1 then y₂ = y₁, which is excluded since the two solutions are distinct; so 1 − u ≠ 0
- du/(1 − u) = (Q/y₁) dx
- −log|1 − u| = ∫(Q/y₁) dx + C
- |1 − u| = e^(−C) e^(−∫(Q/y₁) dx)
Step 4: Write the constant
- 1 − u = −a e^(−∫(Q/y₁) dx), where −a = ±e^(−C)
- u = 1 + a e^(−∫(Q/y₁) dx)
- a = ∓e^(−C) is never zero; a = 0 would give u = 1, i.e. y₂ = y₁
Conclusion
Therefore u = 1 + a e^(−∫(Q/y₁) dx) with a a non-zero constant. Check: differentiating gives u′ = −a(Q/y₁)e^(−∫(Q/y₁)dx) = (Q/y₁)(1 − u), which is the equation of Step 2.
Examples and data to cite
- Consistency check with the general solution: y = y₁ + c e^(−∫P dx); since (y₂ − y₁) also solves the homogeneous equation, y₂ − y₁ = c e^(−∫P dx), and dividing by y₁ gives u − 1 = c e^(−∫P dx)/y₁. Using (1/y₁)′ = −(Q − Py₁)/y₁², one finds e^(−∫P dx)/y₁ is a constant multiple of e^(−∫(Q/y₁)dx), so the two forms agree.
- Simple illustration: y′ + y = 1 has y₁ = 1; here Q/y₁ = 1, so u = 1 + a e^(−x) and y₂ = 1 + a e^(−x), which is exactly the general solution.
Facts to remember
- A linear first order equation has the form y′ + P(x)y = Q(x).
- The difference of two solutions of the non-homogeneous equation solves the homogeneous equation y′ + Py = 0.
- A separable equation du/(1 − u) = g(x) dx integrates to −log|1 − u| = ∫g dx + C.
- The arbitrary constant is non-zero here because y₂ ≠ y₁.