A smooth paraboloid of revolution is fixed with its axis vertical and vertex upwards; on it is placed a heavy elastic string of unstretched length 2πb. When the string is in equilibrium, apply the principle of virtual work to show that it rests in the form of a circle of radius 4πabλ/(4πaλ − Wb), where W is the weight of the string, λ is the modulus of elasticity and 4a is the latus rectum of the generating parabola.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
With the string a horizontal circle of radius r at depth r²/(4a) below the vertex and tension T = λ(r − b)/b, the virtual work equation W·(r/2a)δr − T·2π δr = 0 gives r = 4πabλ/(4πaλ − Wb).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The principle of virtual work lets the reaction of the smooth surface drop out: only gravity and the internal tension of the elastic string do work in a small symmetric displacement. The candidate must set up the geometry of the paraboloid, Hooke's law for the tension and the virtual work equation.
Answer outline
Introduction
Take the vertex as origin and the z axis vertically downward. The generating parabola with latus rectum 4a and vertex upward is r² = 4az, where r is the horizontal distance from the axis and z the depth below the vertex. By symmetry the string rests as a horizontal circle of radius r.
Step 1: Geometry
- Depth of the circle below the vertex: z = r²/(4a)
- The centre of gravity of the uniform string lies on the axis at depth z
- Stretched length = 2πr; natural length = 2πb
Step 2: Tension by Hooke's law
- T = λ × extension/natural length = λ(2πr − 2πb)/(2πb) = λ(r − b)/b
Step 3: Virtual displacement
- Let the circle slide down symmetrically so that r becomes r + δr; the smooth reaction is normal to the surface and does no work
- Change in depth: δz = (2r/4a)δr = (r/2a)δr, so gravity does work W(r/2a)δr
- Length increases by δ(2πr) = 2π δr; the tension opposes extension and does work −T·2π δr
Step 4: Virtual work equation
- W(r/2a)δr − 2πT δr = 0 for arbitrary δr
- Wr/(2a) = 2πλ(r − b)/b
- Wrb = 4πaλ(r − b)
- r(4πaλ − Wb) = 4πabλ
- r = 4πabλ/(4πaλ − Wb)
Conclusion
The string rests as a circle of radius 4πabλ/(4πaλ − Wb). Check: when W → 0 the radius tends to b (no stretching), and the radius is larger than b whenever 4πaλ > Wb, as it must be for a stretched string.
Examples and data to cite
- The same result follows from resolving forces on an element of the string, but that needs the normal reaction; virtual work avoids it, which is why the question asks for it.
- A standard companion problem places the string on a smooth sphere or cone; only the relation between depth and radius (z = r²/4a here) changes.
Facts to remember
- Principle of virtual work: a system with workless constraints is in equilibrium if the total work of the applied forces in any small displacement consistent with the constraints is zero.
- Hooke's law for an elastic string: T = λ × extension/natural length.
- Parabola with vertex at origin and latus rectum 4a: x² = 4ay.
- The reaction of a smooth fixed surface does no work in a displacement along the surface.